Skip to content
Fair Witness portraits: Shelley Moore Capito, West Virginia senator, bill co-author (left), and Catherine Cortez Masto, Nevada senator, voted no (right), side by side.

U.S.

Senate passes permitting reform bill, 62-33, sending it to the House

Faster reviews for power lines and pipelines, and a rule making big data centers pay for their grid upgrades, now depend on the House.

Published 9 min read

Composite of official Senate portraits: Shelley Moore Capito (left), a Republican author of the bill, and Catherine Cortez Masto (right), a Democrat who voted no. Photos: United States Congress / Wikimedia Commons / Public domain (left); U.S. Senate Photographic Studio, Rebecca Hammel / Wikimedia Commons / Public domain (right)

Who covered this

What these mean

The short version

  • The Senate voted 62-33 Thursday night to pass a bipartisan bill that speeds up federal reviews for energy and infrastructure projects.
  • It would make big data centers pay for their grid upgrades and limit lawsuits, and Democratic senators split over tribal and environmental protections.
  • Next, the House decides whether to pass it unchanged, which would send it to Trump, or change it and send it back to the Senate.
Documents in this story · 6
  • RecordRoll call vote No. 270 on passage of H.R. 2347, as amendedU.S. Senate · Web page · Nov. 19Open Archived
  • RecordRoll call votes, 119th Congress, 2nd sessionU.S. Senate · Web pageOpen Archived
  • RecordStatement of Administration Policy on S. 5653Office of Management and Budget · PDF · Nov. 9Original Archived
  • ReleaseStatement on Senate passage of permitting reform billSen. Catherine Cortez Masto · Press release · Nov. 19Open Archived
  • ReleaseStatement on vote against passage of permitting reform legislationSen. Ben Ray Luján · Press release · Nov. 19Open Archived
  • RecordStatement on the Senate's permitting reform billSen. Peter Welch · Web page · Nov. 19Open Archived

The Senate passed a bipartisan permitting reform bill 62-33 Thursday night that would speed up federal reviews of energy projects and make large data centers pay for the grid upgrades they need.

The bill, called the Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act, now goes to the House, and President Donald Trump has said he will sign it. House leaders must choose between passing it as written or changing it and sending it back to the Senate. Republican leaders want it finished in the current session, before Democrats take control of both chambers in January.

Why it matters to you

The bill's backers make their case on power bills. New data centers that draw 20 megawatts or more would pay the full extra cost of the grid built to serve them. States could also charge them higher rates to lower other customers' bills. The administration's own estimate, from the White House Council of Economic Advisers, is that average household electric bills would be $178 to $251 lower, The Washington Times reported. A climate research group, the Center for Climate and Energy Solutions, put savings across all homes at about $2.5 billion a year.

It also changes what you can do about a project near your home. Lawsuits against a project would have to be filed within 150 days of its approval, and only people who weighed in during the formal public comment period could sue. So if a pipeline or power line is proposed nearby, speaking up during that comment period is what would keep your right to go to court.

To see where your own two senators stood, the Senate's roll call lists every vote by name.

What the Senate permitting reform bill would change

Most of the almost 500-page bill rewrites how the government reviews big projects. It sets tighter deadlines for environmental reviews and exempts some work, including expansions of natural gas pipelines, from those reviews. Under the National Environmental Policy Act, the law that requires those reviews, a project a court finds in violation today must stop until it complies. The bill would let it keep going.

Power lines get a faster path. Federal regulators could approve interstate lines if states don't act, which supporters say helps wind and solar farms reach the grid.

The bill also tries to stop presidents from undoing each other's decisions. It would limit when an administration can revoke a permit already granted. That cuts both ways. It would curb Trump's power to block wind projects that already have approval, and the kind of move President Joe Biden made when he revoked the Keystone XL pipeline's permit. Developers could also sue the government if they can show a pattern of unequal treatment of one kind of energy. If they win, taxpayers could have to cover up to 100% of a project's cost.

Sen. Martin Heinrich of New Mexico, the lead Democrat on the bill, pushed for the data center language. He said big users would have to cover their own costs "by statute, not a suggestion, an actual law."

How the vote split both parties

Forty-seven Republicans and 15 Democrats and independents voted yes, the roll call shows. Thirty Democrats voted no, along with Sen. Bernie Sanders, a Vermont independent, and two Republicans, Josh Hawley of Missouri and Mike Rounds of South Dakota. Five senators didn't vote. Senate Democratic leader Chuck Schumer voted yes. New Mexico's two Democrats split: Heinrich voted yes, and Sen. Ben Ray Luján voted no.

The record also shows the bill's form. The Senate passed the text as a rewrite of H.R. 2347, a House bill about the tax treatment of certain legal damages, not under its own Senate number, S. 5653. So what goes to the House is one of its own bills, now carrying the whole permitting deal.

The final tally was lower than it might have been, The Washington Times reported. Negotiators had agreed to allow amendments from both parties. But they could not get every senator's consent to hold those votes, so the bill passed without the changes senators had worked out in recent days. Ten days earlier, 73 senators had voted to start debate.

Years of delays behind the deal

Both energy camps have delays to point to. The 303-mile Mountain Valley gas pipeline through West Virginia and Virginia opened in 2024, a decade after it was proposed, at more than twice its planned cost. New Mexico's SunZia wind project came online in June, 18 years after its developers first asked for federal approval.

Four senators wrote this deal: Republicans Shelley Moore Capito of West Virginia and Mike Lee of Utah, and Democrats Heinrich and Sheldon Whitehouse of Rhode Island. They negotiated with the White House for more than a year. The White House said on Nov. 9 that it strongly supports the bill and that it would "make President Trump's Ratepayer Protection Pledge the law of the land." Days earlier, Democrats had won both chambers in the midterms. Some Democrats now say they should wait for that new Congress to negotiate a better deal.

What we don't know yet

The House hasn't decided whether to pass the Senate's text unchanged. Speaker Mike Johnson is weighing a fast-track vote but faces uncertain Democratic support. House Democratic leader Hakeem Jeffries, whom House Democrats nominated for speaker ahead of the Jan. 3 vote, has signaled serious concerns without opposing it outright. House Majority Leader Steve Scalise said the details matter and the chambers could work out differences. Senate Majority Leader John Thune said he can't predict what happens if the bill comes back to the Senate.

We also don't know when the House will get to it. Its calendar is crowded, including a possible lapse in federal funding. Nor do we know whether the two savings estimates will hold up once utilities and states apply the rules, or whether Hawley will explain his no vote.

The case each side makes

Supporters: cheaper power and projects that get built

Backers say it takes too long to build in the United States, whatever the project. "This landmark bill will benefit every American through more affordable energy," Capito said. Sen. Kevin Cramer, a North Dakota Republican, said the bill gives certainty to everyone, so oil producers in his state and offshore wind projects in Rhode Island would gain alike.

Democratic backers make a climate case. Whitehouse said the bill would lower energy costs, cut emissions and stop what he called data centers' free ride. "Americans will start to get some relief quickly if this bill passes," he said. Adam Jentleson, a former Senate Democratic aide, said the bill clears red tape that kept many of Biden's clean energy projects from breaking ground.

by statute, not a suggestion, an actual law.

Sen. Martin Heinrich, on the bill's data center rules (Fox News)

Opponents: tribal rights, clean water and the courts

Several senators who voted no say they want faster permits too, just not this bill. Sen. Catherine Cortez Masto of Nevada said its changes to the National Historic Preservation Act weaken the consultation tribes are owed by the federal government. "There is no reason to threaten Tribal sovereignty to accomplish these goals," she said after voting no. Luján said he could not back a bill that "fails to address the concerns of our Pueblo and environmental leaders." Before the vote, Sen. Mark Kelly of Arizona said what it would take for his yes vote: "Take out Title III," the section opponents say limits tribal consultation.

Others point to the money and the courts. Sen. Peter Welch of Vermont said the permit rules could force taxpayers to pay developers large damages. He said he was "disappointed the Senate failed to consider these important changes" on clean water and the courts. Among Republicans, Rounds said before the final vote that the bill moves some energy decisions away from local control. We found no public statement from Hawley explaining his no vote as of 6 a.m. ET Friday.

How coverage differs

Readers of right-leaning outlets got the bill's promised savings and none of its tribal objections, which NBC News, CBS News and The Christian Science Monitor put in front of their readers.

If you read the left 6 of 13 outlets

You met the left-right alliance and its critics.

If you read the center 4 of 9 outlets

The fine print came to you.

If you read the right 3 of 12 outlets

Your outlets put the savings first.

Sources

This article was produced by AI under our Editorial Standards. Corrections are reviewed before they go live.

Challenge this article

How coverage differs

Free with a Fair Witness account

See how left, center and right covered this story

A free account shows where the coverage agrees and where it splits, what each side played up and played down, and, when one side's outlets missed a story, who missed it.

Share this story

Challenge this article

Found a factual error? Send us published evidence. We review every submission and correct errors in public.

Keep reading

The newest stories in U.S., then the rest of the site.

Newest · U.S.

ICE arrests two passengers on a Seattle airport jet bridge as they board a flight

Washington's governor said he believes the masked officers broke a new state law, but that law's only penalty is a lawsuit by the people detained.

· 6 min read

A Port of Seattle jet bridge at Gate C20 of Seattle-Tacoma International Airport, where Saturday's arrests happened on one of the jet bridges. Photo, June 2010: Walter Siegmund / Wikimedia Commons / CC BY-SA 3.0

Latest

New stories and updates, newest first. Times are Eastern.

All updates
  1. Nov 22

    12:13 AMTop story U.S.

    ICE arrests two passengers on a Seattle airport jet bridge as they board a flight

    Washington's governor said he believes the masked officers broke a new state law, but that law's only penalty is a lawsuit by the people detained.

  2. Nov 21

    6:12 PMNew Economy

    Trump says he would work with Democrats on a 10% credit card interest rate cap

    The president and Sen. Elizabeth Warren now back a cap that banks and some Republican senators oppose, and no bill has moved yet.

  3. Nov 21

    5:19 PMUpdated Health

    US loses measles elimination status after 26 years, PAHO says

    The finding that measles spreads here again means the U.S. must now stop the spread for a full year to win the status back.

    Spin Meter: how each side framed it · 4/5
  4. Nov 21

    5:17 PMUpdated World

    Mexico captures 'El Chapo Isidro,' an FBI Ten Most Wanted fugitive, in Sinaloa raid

    U.S. prosecutors charged him in 2012, and Mexico has not yet said whether it will send him north to face those charges.

  5. Nov 21

    2:55 PMUpdated U.S.

    House Democrats seek Cantor Fitzgerald's Nvidia records in Lutnick probe

    The letter shows how the House's incoming Democratic chairs plan to test whether Lutnick's handling of Megaspeed was shaped by his family firm's Nvidia stake.

  6. Nov 21

    11:50 PMUpdated U.S.

    Trump orders federal contractors to check with White House before answering Congress

    The order gives the White House a say in what companies doing government work tell Congress, weeks before Democrats take charge and start investigating.

  7. Nov 21

    11:14 PMUpdated Science

    COP31 climate talks run into overtime after draft drops fossil fuels

    Whether the year's climate deal names oil, gas and coal at all now rests on a consensus rule that lets one country block it.

    Out of Frame · Right

  8. Nov 21

    11:12 PMUpdated Science

    BepiColombo enters Mercury orbit, only the second mission to circle the planet

    After an eight-year trip and a year's delay, two orbiters are set to study a planet that only NASA had circled before.

  9. Nov 21

    8:52 PMUpdated U.S.

    Storm that flooded Florida heads up the East Coast as Thanksgiving week nears

    Wind, rain and coastal flooding could reach the Carolinas Saturday and New England by Sunday night, and forecasters see another East Coast storm around Thanksgiving.

  10. Nov 21

    8:37 PMUpdated U.S.

    Cornyn blocks Elliot Gaiser, Trump's pick for a Dallas federal court seat

    A Texas senator's veto can stop a lifetime judgeship, and Republicans have until Jan. 3 to fill the seat before Democrats run the Senate.

  11. Nov 21

    8:36 PMUpdated World

    Russian missile crashes in Poland as strikes hit three Kyiv bridges

    Poland called the crash a likely intentional provocation during allied drills, and NATO's treaty leaves each ally to decide how to respond.

    Edge of Frame · Right

  12. Nov 21

    8:19 PMUpdated Technology

    FBI investigating apparent breach of its national crime database, CNN and NBC report

    Police across the country run warrant and gun checks on the system, and it is the second federal breach reported in a day.

  13. Nov 21

    8:18 PMUpdated U.S.

    Katie Zacharia faces California State Bar investigation over lawyer claims

    The case tests whether California's law making it a crime to claim you can practice law without a license reaches a TV commentator.

The Fair Witness Daily

Get each morning's Spin Meter in your inbox

The Daily leads with the Spin Meter, then the day's explainers. A free account also unlocks every Spin Meter on the site.

Check your inbox to confirm your subscription.

Free. Unsubscribe anytime. Already a member? Sign in