Cornyn blocks Elliot Gaiser, Trump's pick for a Dallas federal court seat
A Texas senator's veto can stop a lifetime judgeship, and Republicans have until Jan. 3 to fill the seat before Democrats run the Senate.
Composite of Texas's Republican senators: John Cornyn (left, 2025), who is blocking Gaiser, and Ted Cruz (right, 2019), who says that gives Democrats the seat. Photos: Office of U.S. Senator John Cornyn / Wikimedia Commons / Public domain (left); U.S. Senate Photographic Studio / Wikimedia Commons / Public domain (right)
Who covered this
On this page · sections
The short version
- Sen. John Cornyn said Wednesday he won't approve Elliot Gaiser, President Trump's pick for a Dallas-area federal court, which stops the nomination.
- Home-state senators can block district court nominees, and Republicans have only until Jan. 3 to confirm Trump's remaining judges.
- Cornyn has offered another candidate, and the White House has asked about him but hasn't said whether it will drop Gaiser.
Sen. John Cornyn of Texas has blocked T. Elliot Gaiser, President Donald Trump's pick for a Dallas-area federal court, by withholding his blue slip, the sign-off a nominee needs from both home-state senators. "I think his nomination is no longer viable," Cornyn told CBS News on Wednesday.
Gaiser, who runs the Justice Department's Office of Legal Counsel, did not appear at the Senate Judiciary Committee's Wednesday hearing, where seven other judicial nominees testified. The fight matters beyond one seat. Republicans are racing to confirm Trump's remaining judges before Democrats take control of the Senate on Jan. 3. Cornyn is the latest Republican to use a home-state veto against the White House's picks.
Why it matters to you
Federal district judges are appointed for life, and they hear the federal lawsuits and criminal cases in their area. This seat is on the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Texas, which covers Dallas. It opened when Judge Jane J. Boyle retired, so whoever fills it could be deciding cases there for decades.
The bigger stake is timing. Once Democrats hold the Senate, few if any of Trump's picks for the appeals and district courts are expected to win confirmation, CBS News reported. If no nominee for this seat is confirmed by Jan. 3, the choice will run through a Democratic-led Senate, and a new Texas senator.
How the Gaiser nomination moved so fast
Gaiser's own paperwork shows how quickly this came together. In his questionnaire to the committee, he said Sen. Ted Cruz's staff first contacted him about the seat on Nov. 4, the day after the midterm elections. He talked with Cornyn's office on Nov. 6, dated his questionnaire Nov. 7, and Trump announced the pick on Nov. 10.
The committee's nomination record shows the nomination reached the Senate on Nov. 16, two days before the hearing he was expected to attend. Sen. Dick Durbin of Illinois, the committee's top Democrat, said on Nov. 10 that Republicans were breaking committee practice by scheduling nominees whose questionnaires arrived less than 28 days before a hearing.
Gaiser, 37, is a former Ohio solicitor general who clerked for Justice Samuel Alito. His one tie to Texas appears to be a year clerking for a federal appeals judge in Houston, CBS News reported. As head of the Office of Legal Counsel, he wrote the legal opinion supporting U.S. military strikes on suspected drug boats and an April opinion calling the Presidential Records Act unconstitutional.
We found no public comment from Gaiser himself as of 6 p.m. ET Wednesday. The Justice Department defended him: a spokesperson told Newsweek he is a highly qualified nominee.
How a blue slip can stop a judge
The blue slip is a Senate custom, not a rule in the Constitution. When a president picks a district judge, the committee sends a slip of paper to the two senators from the nominee's state. A district court nominee gets a hearing only if both senators return it with approval. Trump has pushed committee chairman Chuck Grassley, an Iowa Republican, to scrap the custom, but Grassley has kept it for district judges and U.S. attorneys.
Cornyn isn't the only Republican using it this month. The White House withdrew Judge Lee Rudofsky's nomination to a federal appeals court on Nov. 10 after Arkansas' two Republican senators opposed him. It then picked Arkansas Supreme Court Justice J. Cody Hiland, who testified Wednesday. Sen. Alan Armstrong of Oklahoma, who is leaving office, has blocked a nominee from his state. Sen. Thom Tillis of North Carolina had his own message for the White House last week. "Treat us like the U.S. Senate," he told the AP.
Cornyn's own race adds a twist, because it decides who holds his blue slip next. He lost his Republican primary to Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton, whom Trump backed. Paxton then lost to Democrat James Talarico, who will replace Cornyn. That result was part of the Democratic wins that gave the party the Senate. When Talarico is sworn in on Jan. 3, Durbin said, he will hold Texas's second blue slip and "has the right, as all Senators do" to approve or reject district court picks.
Who Cornyn wants instead
Cornyn has recommended Steve Fahey, a Fort Worth lawyer who was a federal prosecutor in the Northern District of Texas from 2003 to 2021. Fahey was a partner at Kirkland & Ellis until 2024. Cornyn told the AP the White House has asked for information about Fahey. But he did not know whether Gaiser would be formally withdrawn.
Gaiser's seat is one of many the White House wants filled. The Senate confirmed a Colorado judge to an appeals court on Monday, with 22 other judicial picks still pending as the White House pushed for votes.
What we don't know yet
The White House hasn't said whether it will drop Gaiser for Fahey or keep Gaiser's nomination and leave the seat open. Its request for information on Fahey suggests it is weighing him, but it has not named a new nominee. A new pick would also need a questionnaire, a hearing, a committee vote and a floor vote before Jan. 3.
It is also unclear whether Gaiser will stay at the Office of Legal Counsel or comment on the block. And if the seat is still open in January, no one has said how Cruz and Talarico would handle a new nominee.
The case each side makes
Cornyn: the Senate's say over a lifetime job
Cornyn says the problem is the process, not Gaiser's intelligence. He said Gaiser is not a Texan, has no trial experience and was never screened by the bipartisan committee Texas senators use to vet judicial candidates. He called him a bright young lawyer who was "used basically as a pawn in this process," the AP reported.
His deeper argument is about the Senate's role under the Constitution's advice-and-consent clause. The White House, he said, wouldn't let senators do the due diligence a lifetime appointment needs. Last week he also pointed to Gaiser's work advising Trump's 2020 campaign on its election challenges, the AP reported. The Senate is not supposed to be a rubber stamp, he said Tuesday, and too often it has been. He has said he wants the seat filled, just not by Gaiser.
I think his nomination is no longer viable
Cruz and the White House: fill the seat while Republicans can
Cruz's case is about who ends up with the seat. If Gaiser doesn't advance, Cruz said in a statement, the block "will effectively give the judicial seat to the Democrats," who he warned would keep it empty for good.
He also argues that speed is normal at the end of a Senate majority. At Wednesday's hearing, Cruz pointed to the judges Democrats confirmed quickly in late 2024 before they lost control. In the statements we found, the White House did not answer Cornyn's objections directly. "We expect all judicial nominees pending in the Senate to be confirmed this year," a White House official said in a statement. The Justice Department went further. "It is deeply disappointing that Senator Cornyn would choose political obstruction," a spokesperson told Newsweek.
Sources
Left
3 of 13 left-leaning outlets we track reported this
- CBS News: Cornyn blocks Trump's nomination of top DOJ official to federal district court in Texas, Nov. 18
- CNN: Sen. Cornyn blocks judicial nominee because Trump didn't choose Texas, Nov. 18
- Associated Press: Cornyn blocks top Justice Department official nominated for judicial vacancy in Texas, Nov. 18
- Associated Press (via WKMG ClickOrlando): White House faces unusual obstacle on confirming Trump judges: other Republicans, Nov. 11
- Associated Press (via Spectrum News): Democrats win control of Senate, House, Nov. 3
Center
2 of 9 center outlets we track reported this
Right
3 of 12 right-leaning outlets we track reported this
This article was produced by AI under our Editorial Standards. Corrections are reviewed before they go live.
How coverage differs
Free with a Fair Witness account
See how left, center and right covered this story
A free account shows where the coverage agrees and where it splits, what each side played up and played down, and, when one side's outlets missed a story, who missed it.
Keep reading
The newest stories in U.S., then the rest of the site.
Newest · U.S.
Susan Smith denied parole again, 32 years after drowning her two sons
The unanimous vote keeps her in prison at least until 2028, when state law gives her another chance to ask.
Latest
New stories and updates, newest first. Times are Eastern.
-
Nov 19
3:37 PMTop story World
UN top court rules Myanmar committed genocide against the Rohingya
The world court had never held a state responsible for genocide, and the ruling is expected to echo in South Africa's case against Israel.
Edge of Frame · Right
-
Nov 19
2:16 PMUpdated U.S.
NSA's classified network goes down; White House says no sign of a cyberattack
The intelligence agency's internal system for sharing secrets failed in a week of U.S. tech outages, and Democrats want a briefing.
-
Nov 19
2:15 PMUpdated U.S.
South Florida flooding shuts Broward, Miami-Dade schools after up to 15 inches of rain
Forecasters say even an inch or two more rain could flood soaked neighborhoods Thursday, and Fort Lauderdale's king tides are due next week.
-
Nov 19
12:01 PMNew U.S.
Florida pastor convicted in plot tied to assassination of Haiti's President Moïse
Prosecutors say the plot to kill Haiti's president was planned in South Florida and paid for partly with U.S. pandemic aid.
Edge of Frame · Right
-
Nov 19
11:13 AMUpdated World
Iran fires on U.S. air base in Kuwait and at Bahrain after U.S. strike on Qeshm
Iran's first attack on Kuwait in two months widens a weeklong exchange of fire, and Washington has not said how it will answer.
Edge of Frame · Left
-
Nov 19
3:35 PMTop story U.S.
Susan Smith denied parole again, 32 years after drowning her two sons
The unanimous vote keeps her in prison at least until 2028, when state law gives her another chance to ask.
-
Nov 19
3:33 PMTop story Technology
JPMorgan Chase says hackers hit its vendors and may have taken customer names, emails
The bank says marketing records were reached, but a reported leak of wealthy clients' data may mean more, and the near-term risk is phishing.
-
Nov 19
3:31 PMNew World
Danish parliament approves U.S.-Greenland security deal, 109-0
The last vote is done, but the deal has no end date and leaves open what the U.S. will build on Greenland, and when.
-
Nov 19
3:23 PMUpdated Economy
Anthropic IPO priced at $83 a share, raising $81.3 billion before Nasdaq debut
Shares began trading Thursday, and a new Nasdaq rule could soon put them in index funds that many 401(k) savers already own.
-
Nov 19
2:19 PMUpdated U.S.
New Orleans tanker crash: Coast Guard cites loss of steering; everyone accounted for
No one died when a tanker struck a docked riverboat. Investigators now want to know why a ship guided by a river pilot lost control.
-
Nov 19
2:19 PMUpdated World
Trump, Xi and Putin hold first three-way talks in Shenzhen; no nuclear deal announced
With no treaty now limiting U.S. and Russian arsenals, the three leaders opened far apart: Trump sought cuts, while Xi, by China's account, urged abolition.
-
Nov 19
2:17 PMUpdated World
Part of Crimean Bridge collapses after Ukrainian strike as Russia hits Kyiv's bridges
Each side hit bridges it calls military routes, two days before Trump meets Putin and Xi in China.
-
Nov 19
2:17 PMUpdated World
U.S. strikes Iran's Qeshm Island after third Iranian attack on Bahrain, officials say
It is the U.S. reply to Iranian attacks that ended a two-month lull, and Iran's next move will show whether the exchange keeps going.
The Fair Witness Daily
Get each morning's Spin Meter in your inbox
The Daily leads with the Spin Meter, then the day's explainers. A free account also unlocks every Spin Meter on the site.
Free. Unsubscribe anytime. Already a member? Sign in