Skip to content
Fair Witness graphic: chart. Share of parole-eligible inmates paroled, by risk rating, FY2025, High risk to Low risk; latest, 10% (Low risk), according to S.C. Department of Probation…

U.S.

Susan Smith denied parole again, 32 years after drowning her two sons

The unanimous vote keeps her in prison at least until 2028, when state law gives her another chance to ask.

Published 6 min read

Share of parole-eligible South Carolina inmates paroled in the year to June 2025, by the parole agency's risk rating, from its report to lawmakers. Chart: Fair Witness; data: S.C. Department of Probation, Parole and Pardon Services

Who covered this

What these mean

The short version

  • South Carolina's parole board unanimously denied Susan Smith parole Thursday, 32 years after she drowned her two young sons in a lake.
  • Smith told the board she has changed, while the boys' father and her trial prosecutor urged the board to keep her in prison.
  • State law sets her next parole review for two years from now, in 2028.
Documents in this story · 5
  • Report2025 Sentencing Reform Oversight Committee report (PDF), parole risk assessment outcomes, p. 15S.C. Department of Probation, Parole and Pardon Services · PDFOriginal Archived
  • ReleaseNews releasesS.C. Department of Probation, Parole and Pardon Services · Press releaseOpen Archived
  • StatuteSections 24-21-30 (parole votes) and 24-21-645 (reviews every two years)South Carolina Code, Title 24, Chapter 21 · Web pageOpen Archived
  • StatuteSection 16-3-20 (punishment for murder)South Carolina Code, Title 16, Chapter 3 · Web pageOpen Archived
  • RecordRep. Tommy Pope, member pageSouth Carolina Legislature · Web pageOpen Archived

South Carolina's parole board denied Susan Smith parole for a second time Thursday, 32 years after she drowned her two young sons in a lake. The board voted unanimously against her release, and she can ask again in 2028.

The hearing set her account of a changed life against the boys' father and the prosecutor who sent her to prison. The board sided with them, as it did two years ago.

How Susan Smith's second parole hearing unfolded

Smith, now 55, joined the hearing by video from Leath Correctional Institution in Greenwood, South Carolina. To go free, she needed two-thirds of the seven-member board on her side, the margin state law requires for a violent crime. Newsweek reported that one member recused herself because she had once been acting warden at a prison where Smith was held, so the others decided the case.

Smith told the board that her sons were innocent and had done nothing to deserve their deaths, and she apologized for killing them. "I'm not the same person I was 32 years ago," she said. Her lawyer said she has no other criminal record and would be a low risk to commit another crime. A psychologist, Jessie Hill, testified that her mental illness had eased greatly with medicine, menopause and the deaths of her mother and stepfather. She also disputed the prosecution's long-held account of her motive, WSOC-TV reported.

The boys' father, David Smith, came to Columbia to argue the opposite. He wore the same photo of his sons pinned over his heart that he wore to her 1995 trial. He told the board the killings were deliberate, not an accident. "I'm here to advocate for Michael and Alex, not for me," he said.

Tommy Pope prosecuted her and is now the speaker pro tempore of the South Carolina House. He told the board she enjoyed the attention her lie brought her and has sought it from prison since. Before the hearing, he told Fox News Digital that her apology was about herself. "Her remorse is for her circumstances, not for those boys," Pope said.

Why a 1994 murder case is still before the parole board

The crime that brought Smith here began with a lie. In October 1994, she said a Black man had carjacked her and driven off with her sons, setting off a nine-day search that drew attention around the world. In fact, she had let her car roll into John D. Long Lake near Union with Michael, 3, and Alex, 14 months, strapped inside. The AP said her false story played on an old racist image of Black men as a threat to white women.

At her trial, prosecutors said she killed the boys after a man she was having an affair with ended it because he did not want children. Her defense said she had a severe breakdown and meant to die with them. The jury convicted her of murder but chose life in prison over the death penalty.

That sentence is why she can ask for parole at all. Under the law when she was sentenced, a life term allowed a parole request after 30 years. Today, state law defines a life sentence for murder as lasting until death without the possibility of parole.

Her first try came in November 2024. David Smith and 14 other witnesses spoke against her release, and the board turned her down unanimously, citing the seriousness of the crimes and her prison record. Months before that hearing, she was charged under prison rules over phone calls with a documentary filmmaker.

How rarely South Carolina grants parole

The board granted parole in only 4% of the cases before it, and most of the paroles were in nonviolent cases, the AP reported from the agency's statistics. When the board turns down someone convicted of a violent crime, state law sets a fresh review every two years.

Her lawyer's case leaned on her low risk, and the agency's own numbers put that in context. In the year to June 2025, the agency's risk tool rated 1,137 parole-eligible inmates as low risk. Only about 1 in 10 of them won parole, according to the agency's 2025 report to state lawmakers. Most inmates the tool rated low risk were turned down, though the report cautions that its figures can't be used to work out an overall parole rate.

I'm not the same person I was 32 years ago.

Susan Smith, to the South Carolina parole board, Nov. 19 (AP via The Washington Times)

What we don't know yet

As of 3 p.m. ET Thursday, the board had not made public its reasons for turning Smith down this time. We found no notice of the decision on the parole agency's website. In 2024 the board pointed to the crime and her prison record, and only the second of those can change.

If she asks again, her case returns in 2028. Pope has said he will stand with David Smith every two years for as long as it takes to keep her in prison.

Sources

This article was produced by AI under our Editorial Standards. Corrections are reviewed before they go live.

Challenge this article

How coverage differs

Free with a Fair Witness account

See how left, center and right covered this story

A free account shows where the coverage agrees and where it splits, what each side played up and played down, and, when one side's outlets missed a story, who missed it.

Share this story

Challenge this article

Found a factual error? Send us published evidence. We review every submission and correct errors in public.

Keep reading

The newest stories in U.S., then the rest of the site.

Newest · U.S.

Edge of Frame · Right

Florida pastor convicted in plot tied to assassination of Haiti's President Moïse

Prosecutors say the plot to kill Haiti's president was planned in South Florida and paid for partly with U.S. pandemic aid.

· 8 min read

Haitian President Jovenel Moïse, right, and his wife, Martine, at an official welcome in Taiwan, three years before he was killed. Photo, May 29, 2018: Office of the President of Taiwan / Wikimedia Commons / CC BY 2.0

Latest

New stories and updates, newest first. Times are Eastern.

All updates
  1. Nov 19

    3:37 PMTop story World

    UN top court rules Myanmar committed genocide against the Rohingya

    The world court had never held a state responsible for genocide, and the ruling is expected to echo in South Africa's case against Israel.

    Edge of Frame · Right

  2. Nov 19

    2:16 PMUpdated U.S.

    NSA's classified network goes down; White House says no sign of a cyberattack

    The intelligence agency's internal system for sharing secrets failed in a week of U.S. tech outages, and Democrats want a briefing.

  3. Nov 19

    2:15 PMUpdated U.S.

    South Florida flooding shuts Broward, Miami-Dade schools after up to 15 inches of rain

    Forecasters say even an inch or two more rain could flood soaked neighborhoods Thursday, and Fort Lauderdale's king tides are due next week.

  4. Nov 19

    12:01 PMNew U.S.

    Florida pastor convicted in plot tied to assassination of Haiti's President Moïse

    Prosecutors say the plot to kill Haiti's president was planned in South Florida and paid for partly with U.S. pandemic aid.

    Edge of Frame · Right

  5. Nov 19

    11:13 AMUpdated World

    Iran fires on U.S. air base in Kuwait and at Bahrain after U.S. strike on Qeshm

    Iran's first attack on Kuwait in two months widens a weeklong exchange of fire, and Washington has not said how it will answer.

    Edge of Frame · Left

  6. Nov 19

    3:35 PMTop story U.S.

    Susan Smith denied parole again, 32 years after drowning her two sons

    The unanimous vote keeps her in prison at least until 2028, when state law gives her another chance to ask.

  7. Nov 19

    3:33 PMTop story Technology

    JPMorgan Chase says hackers hit its vendors and may have taken customer names, emails

    The bank says marketing records were reached, but a reported leak of wealthy clients' data may mean more, and the near-term risk is phishing.

  8. Nov 19

    3:31 PMNew World

    Danish parliament approves U.S.-Greenland security deal, 109-0

    The last vote is done, but the deal has no end date and leaves open what the U.S. will build on Greenland, and when.

  9. Nov 19

    3:23 PMUpdated Economy

    Anthropic IPO priced at $83 a share, raising $81.3 billion before Nasdaq debut

    Shares began trading Thursday, and a new Nasdaq rule could soon put them in index funds that many 401(k) savers already own.

  10. Nov 19

    2:19 PMUpdated U.S.

    New Orleans tanker crash: Coast Guard cites loss of steering; everyone accounted for

    No one died when a tanker struck a docked riverboat. Investigators now want to know why a ship guided by a river pilot lost control.

  11. Nov 19

    2:19 PMUpdated World

    Trump, Xi and Putin hold first three-way talks in Shenzhen; no nuclear deal announced

    With no treaty now limiting U.S. and Russian arsenals, the three leaders opened far apart: Trump sought cuts, while Xi, by China's account, urged abolition.

  12. Nov 19

    2:17 PMUpdated World

    Part of Crimean Bridge collapses after Ukrainian strike as Russia hits Kyiv's bridges

    Each side hit bridges it calls military routes, two days before Trump meets Putin and Xi in China.

  13. Nov 19

    2:17 PMUpdated World

    U.S. strikes Iran's Qeshm Island after third Iranian attack on Bahrain, officials say

    It is the U.S. reply to Iranian attacks that ended a two-month lull, and Iran's next move will show whether the exchange keeps going.

The Fair Witness Daily

Get each morning's Spin Meter in your inbox

The Daily leads with the Spin Meter, then the day's explainers. A free account also unlocks every Spin Meter on the site.

Check your inbox to confirm your subscription.

Free. Unsubscribe anytime. Already a member? Sign in