Second judge blocks Trump's arch near Arlington cemetery, calling it a 'rushed job'
A Virginia judge's order has no end date and can be appealed now, unlike the pause in Washington that runs through Dec. 3.
Memorial Circle, at the Virginia end of Arlington Memorial Bridge, is the planned site of President Trump's arch. Photo, January 2009: michiel1972 / Wikimedia Commons / CC BY-SA 3.0
Who covered this
The story so far
The court fight over Trump's Arlington arch
On this page · sections
The short version
- A federal judge in Virginia said Friday she will block construction of President Trump's 250-foot arch near Arlington National Cemetery.
- She is the second judge to halt the project, and her order has no end date, unlike the Washington pause that runs through Dec. 3.
- The Justice Department says it will appeal immediately, while the judge in Washington weighs a longer block of her own.
Documents in this story · 5
- RulingOrder extending the temporary restraining order, Lemmon v. TrumpU.S. District Court for D.C. · PDF · Nov. 18Original Archived
- RulingMemorandum opinion granting a temporary restraining orderU.S. District Court for D.C. · PDF · Nov. 5Original Archived
- RulingAmended complaint, County Board of Arlington County v. National Park ServiceArlington County · PDF · Nov. 6Original Archived
- StatuteAppeals from orders granting injunctions (Cornell Legal Information Institute)28 U.S.C. 1292 · Web pageOpen Archived
- RecordCourt home pageU.S. Court of Appeals for the 4th Circuit · Web pageOpen Archived
A second federal judge blocked President Donald Trump's planned 250-foot arch near Arlington National Cemetery on Friday, calling the government's push to build it a "rushed job" without Congress's approval.
U.S. District Judge Leonie Brinkema, ruling from the bench in Alexandria, Va., said she would issue a preliminary injunction, an order that freezes the project while Arlington County's lawsuit goes forward. Unlike the pause a judge in Washington ordered this month, hers has no end date. A Justice Department spokesperson said the department would appeal immediately.
That gives the arch's opponents a block that lasts, and it gives the government its first chance to take the fight straight to a higher court. Fair Witness reported Nov. 11 on the separate case in Washington, where Judge Tanya Chutkan's pause now runs through Dec. 3.
Why it matters to you
If you cross Arlington Memorial Bridge or fly in and out of Ronald Reagan Washington National Airport, the ruling keeps construction off your route for now. Emergency crews serving the airport and Arlington National Cemetery rely on the bridge, and construction would slow them, Brinkema said. Reuters put the site 3,000 feet from the airport, inside its main approach and departure corridor. How long that lasts now turns on the appeal.
Why a second judge blocked Trump's arch
Brinkema said the National Park Service's study of the arch's effects had several defects. Among them, she said, was too little explanation of the effect on Reagan National. In September, the Federal Aviation Administration found it would not be a hazard to aircraft as long as it carried a light on top and floodlights aimed at it so pilots could see it. Politico put the airport farther away than Reuters did, about three miles south of the site.
Justice Department lawyers argue that a 1925 law, which authorized Memorial Bridge, still gives agencies the power to build the arch. Brinkema rejected that. "It hurts your credibility with the court by focusing on that," she told government lawyers. She went further: "I don't see any way where the defense could be successful," she said.
Two courts, two kinds of orders
The two orders work differently, and that shapes the next round. Chutkan's is a temporary restraining order, a short emergency pause. Her Nov. 18 order explains that such pauses usually last 14 days plus one 14-day extension, and that one kept longer than 28 days becomes reviewable by an appeals court. Hers runs exactly 28 days, from Nov. 5 through Dec. 3, or until she rules on the challengers' requests for a longer block.
A preliminary injunction is a different tool. Federal law lets the losing side appeal an order granting an injunction without waiting for the case to end. That is why the Justice Department can move now. An appeal from Alexandria goes to the 4th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals in Richmond, Va.
How Arlington County's lawsuit got here
Arlington County's board sued in October, the first local government to go to court over the arch. Its amended complaint accuses the Park Service of a "feverish pace" toward construction. It says the agency skipped the deeper study federal law requires for major projects, and that the work would clog roads the county's emergency crews use.
I don't see any way where the defense could be successful.
The Washington case is older. Three Vietnam War veterans and an architectural historian sued in February, and D.C. and Virginia followed on Oct. 31, Chutkan's order recounts. In her Nov. 5 opinion, Chutkan wrote that "Congress has not enacted any statute authorizing construction of the Arch." The same opinion notes that the 1925 law allowed design changes only without raising the project's total cost. Nine Kennedy relatives have asked to join that case, as we reported, and their request is still pending.
What each side said after Friday's ruling
Arlington's lawyers said the ruling protects people who live and work in Arlington. The court had stopped "the massive vanity project while our case is heard," said Kate Talmor of Democracy Forward, which represents the county. The county's board chair, Matt de Ferranti, said in October that Arlington has the most to lose from the project.
The White House said it would keep fighting. The judiciary "should not be abused to politicize a structure designed to unite our nation," spokesman Davis Ingle said, adding that the administration expects to be fully vindicated. The administration has defended the arch as a tribute to veterans, and the Justice Department put its next step in one line: "We will appeal the district court's decision immediately," spokesperson Matthew Nies said.
What we don't know yet
What Brinkema's injunction covers won't be clear until we see her written order. Reports Friday covered only her remarks from the bench.
We also don't know how fast the 4th Circuit will act, or whether it will let work start while the appeal goes on. In Washington, Chutkan could rule on a longer block of her own any day before Dec. 3, and she hasn't decided whether the Kennedy family may join. The cost is open, too. The New York Post called it a $1 billion project, while the AP reported estimates as high as $100 million. The White House's project site doesn't say what it would cost or who would pay.
How coverage differs
Readers of left-leaning outlets got both the White House's answer to Friday's ruling and the Justice Department's vow to appeal. Just The News gave right-leaning readers the appeal; Reuters, the center's Friday report, had neither.
If you read the left 8 of 13 outlets
You heard both sides answer.
If you read the center 3 of 9 outlets
Reuters was your Friday report.
If you read the right 4 of 12 outlets
Your reports split on the price.
Sources
Left
8 of 13 left-leaning outlets we track reported this
- Politico: 2nd federal judge blocks Trump's triumphal arch, Nov. 20
- Axios: Second judge blocks Trump's contested D.C. arch, Nov. 20
- CNN: Second judge blocks Trump's triumphal arch, saying it lacks congressional approval, Nov. 20
- AP via PBS NewsHour: Trump's memorial arch faces a new lawsuit from Arlington County, Virginia, Oct. 9
- AP via PBS NewsHour: Trump says the towering arch he wants to build might be dedicated to military veterans, Nov. 11
- NPR: A second judge blocks Trump's arch, saying it's unlikely to succeed in court, Nov. 20
Center
3 of 9 center outlets we track reported this
Right
4 of 12 right-leaning outlets we track reported this
- New York Post: Second judge blocks Trump's $1B Triumphal Arch project near Arlington, Nov. 20
- Fox News: Trump's massive DC triumphal arch project dealt another blow by federal judge, Nov. 19
- The Washington Times: Trump's triumphal arch blocked for another two weeks, Nov. 18
- Just The News: Second federal judge blocks Trump's monumental arch construction, Nov. 20
Primary
- U.S. District Court for D.C.: Order extending the temporary restraining order, Lemmon v. Trump, Nov. 18 · Archived copy
- U.S. District Court for D.C.: Memorandum opinion granting a temporary restraining order, Nov. 5 · Archived copy
- Arlington County: Amended complaint, County Board of Arlington County v. National Park Service, Nov. 6 · Archived copy
- 28 U.S.C. 1292: Appeals from orders granting injunctions (Cornell Legal Information Institute) · Archived copy
- U.S. Court of Appeals for the 4th Circuit: Court home page · Archived copy
This article was produced by AI under our Editorial Standards. Corrections are reviewed before they go live.
How coverage differs
Free with a Fair Witness account
See how left, center and right covered this story
A free account shows where the coverage agrees and where it splits, what each side played up and played down, and, when one side's outlets missed a story, who missed it.
Keep reading
The newest stories in U.S., then the rest of the site.
Newest · U.S.
ICE arrests two passengers on a Seattle airport jet bridge as they board a flight
Washington's governor said he believes the masked officers broke a new state law, but that law's only penalty is a lawsuit by the people detained.
Latest
New stories and updates, newest first. Times are Eastern.
-
Nov 22
12:13 AMTop story U.S.
ICE arrests two passengers on a Seattle airport jet bridge as they board a flight
Washington's governor said he believes the masked officers broke a new state law, but that law's only penalty is a lawsuit by the people detained.
-
Nov 21
6:12 PMNew Economy
Trump says he would work with Democrats on a 10% credit card interest rate cap
The president and Sen. Elizabeth Warren now back a cap that banks and some Republican senators oppose, and no bill has moved yet.
-
Nov 21
5:19 PMUpdated Health
US loses measles elimination status after 26 years, PAHO says
The finding that measles spreads here again means the U.S. must now stop the spread for a full year to win the status back.
Spin Meter: how each side framed it · 4/5 -
Nov 21
5:17 PMUpdated World
Mexico captures 'El Chapo Isidro,' an FBI Ten Most Wanted fugitive, in Sinaloa raid
U.S. prosecutors charged him in 2012, and Mexico has not yet said whether it will send him north to face those charges.
-
Nov 21
2:55 PMUpdated U.S.
House Democrats seek Cantor Fitzgerald's Nvidia records in Lutnick probe
The letter shows how the House's incoming Democratic chairs plan to test whether Lutnick's handling of Megaspeed was shaped by his family firm's Nvidia stake.
-
Nov 21
11:50 PMUpdated U.S.
Trump orders federal contractors to check with White House before answering Congress
The order gives the White House a say in what companies doing government work tell Congress, weeks before Democrats take charge and start investigating.
-
Nov 21
11:14 PMUpdated Science
COP31 climate talks run into overtime after draft drops fossil fuels
Whether the year's climate deal names oil, gas and coal at all now rests on a consensus rule that lets one country block it.
Out of Frame · Right
-
Nov 21
11:12 PMUpdated Science
BepiColombo enters Mercury orbit, only the second mission to circle the planet
After an eight-year trip and a year's delay, two orbiters are set to study a planet that only NASA had circled before.
-
Nov 21
8:52 PMUpdated U.S.
Storm that flooded Florida heads up the East Coast as Thanksgiving week nears
Wind, rain and coastal flooding could reach the Carolinas Saturday and New England by Sunday night, and forecasters see another East Coast storm around Thanksgiving.
-
Nov 21
8:37 PMUpdated U.S.
Cornyn blocks Elliot Gaiser, Trump's pick for a Dallas federal court seat
A Texas senator's veto can stop a lifetime judgeship, and Republicans have until Jan. 3 to fill the seat before Democrats run the Senate.
-
Nov 21
8:36 PMUpdated World
Russian missile crashes in Poland as strikes hit three Kyiv bridges
Poland called the crash a likely intentional provocation during allied drills, and NATO's treaty leaves each ally to decide how to respond.
Edge of Frame · Right
-
Nov 21
8:19 PMUpdated Technology
FBI investigating apparent breach of its national crime database, CNN and NBC report
Police across the country run warrant and gun checks on the system, and it is the second federal breach reported in a day.
-
Nov 21
8:18 PMUpdated U.S.
Katie Zacharia faces California State Bar investigation over lawyer claims
The case tests whether California's law making it a crime to claim you can practice law without a license reaches a TV commentator.
The Fair Witness Daily
Get each morning's Spin Meter in your inbox
The Daily leads with the Spin Meter, then the day's explainers. A free account also unlocks every Spin Meter on the site.
Free. Unsubscribe anytime. Already a member? Sign in