Mamdani's plan to close Rikers Island by 2032 would push past the 2027 legal deadline
The new date needs a City Council vote, and the plan works only if the city holds over a third fewer people in jail.
Rikers Island from above, its jail buildings spread across the island the city's plan would stop using as a jail by 2032. Photo, March 2006: U.S. Geological Survey / Wikimedia Commons / Public domain
Who covered this
On this page · sections
The short version
- New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani released a plan Friday to close the Rikers Island jails by the end of 2032.
- That is more than five years after the August 2027 deadline in city law, and it depends on holding far fewer people in jail.
- The City Council must pass a law to move the deadline, and the Council plans an oversight hearing in December.
Documents in this story · 4
- ReleaseMayor Mamdani releases city's first comprehensive plan to close Rikers IslandNYC Mayor's Office · Press release · Nov. 20Open Archived
- RecordThe Close Rikers Strategic PlanCity of New York · Web page · Nov. 20Open Archived
- RecordClose Rikers plan summary and timelineCity of New York · Web pageOpen Archived
- RecordInt. 1592-A, enacted as Local Law 16 of 2021, transfer of Rikers IslandNew York City Council · Web pageOpen Archived
New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani released a plan Friday to close Rikers Island by the end of 2032, more than five years past the August 2027 deadline set in city law.
The new date isn't his to set. The City Council must pass a law moving the deadline, and the plan works only if the city holds far fewer people in jail than it does today. The plan's own numbers show how big that gap is.
Why it matters to you
The city has set aside about $16.1 billion of New Yorkers' money for the four replacement jails. The mayor also wants $146 million next fiscal year for mental health care, addiction treatment, job training and victim services. If you want a say, the City Council plans an oversight hearing in December, the first public chance to weigh in.
If someone close to you is held at Rikers, the plan changes how you pay bail and, later, where you visit. The city says it will restore its online bail payment portal in 2027, which has been down since 2023. The new jails would sit near courthouses and public transit, which would make visits easier.
Readers elsewhere have a stake too. Vera Institute of Justice president Insha Rahman, who backs the plan, told NPR that cities such as Los Angeles and Chicago could follow if New York succeeds.
What Mamdani's plan to close Rikers Island would do
The plan opens the new jails one at a time: Brooklyn in 2029, the Bronx and Queens in 2031, and Manhattan in 2032. Each would hold 1,040 beds. Women would be held together at the Queens jail near Elmhurst Hospital. People with serious mental illness or complex medical needs would move to hospital units, with 236 new beds in Brooklyn and the Bronx on top of 104 already open at Bellevue.
Mamdani released the plan in a video on X with Correction Commissioner Stanley Richards, who was once held at Rikers himself. At City Hall, Mamdani described the new date as "a new timeline made necessary by the prior administration's delays."
The rest of the plan is about keeping people out of jail in the first place. Most people held at Rikers are awaiting trial, and nearly a quarter have been held for more than a year. So the plan would expand diversion and supervised release, fund advocates who challenge unaffordable bail, and upgrade electronic monitoring. A new task force with the courts, district attorneys and defense lawyers would work on case delays.
The arithmetic the plan has to beat
The plan itself gives the numbers that decide whether this can work. The four jails hold 4,160 beds, and with the hospital units the system can hold about 4,500 people. The city held 6,542 people in late August.
The targets are no more than 5,500 when Brooklyn opens in 2029, and no more than 4,100, including 220 women, by the end of 2032. Reaching that goal means holding about 2,400 fewer people, more than a third of the August count, and leaves a cushion of about 400 beds. It also explains why outlets reported different goals: some gave the 4,100 target, others the roughly 4,500 the jails can hold.
The plan argues there is "more than enough room to reduce the population to the borough-based capacity." But it says plainly that it is not yet forecasting jail numbers, and it doesn't say what happens if the count stays high. Much of the work depends on judges and district attorneys, over whom the mayor has no control.
How the 2027 deadline got into law
The August 2027 date comes from a law the Council introduced in 2019 and enacted in February 2021, after it voted in 2019 to replace Rikers with four borough jails. Its wording is more exact than a closing date. It says that by Aug. 31, 2027, "all portions of Rikers Island shall be fully transferred" from the Correction Department to the city's property agency and no longer used to hold people.
That handover has started in pieces. In June, the city closed the empty North Infirmary Command and moved it and large parts of two other jails to the property agency.
Conditions inside the jails are what drew a federal judge in. More than 50 people have died in city custody since 2022, almost all of them held at Rikers. In 2025, the judge took control of the jails from the city and handed them to an outside manager, who took the post in January. That remediation manager, Nicholas Deml, has his own plan to bring the jails into line with the law, and the city says it will carry out its plan with him and the federal monitor.
We have a legal and moral obligation to close Rikers.
What we don't know yet
Whether the City Council will move the deadline to 2032, and on what terms, is still open. No bill is before the Council yet. Council Member Sandy Nurse is expected to sponsor one, and the criminal justice committee chair, Selvena Brooks-Powers, said 2027 is "not feasible" but didn't commit to 2032. The bill is expected to set benchmark dates along the way. Which ones, and what happens if the city misses them, will decide how binding 2032 really is.
Nobody can yet say whether the jail population will fall far enough. The plan promises quarterly progress reports, which will show how the count is moving toward the 5,500 goal set for 2029.
We also don't know how the officers who staff the jails see the plan. We found no public response from the Correction Officers' Benevolent Association, their union, as of 11:30 a.m. ET Friday, and none from Republican members of the City Council.
The case each side makes
The case for the 2032 plan
The mayor argues the city is bound to finish what it started. "We have a legal and moral obligation to close Rikers," Mamdani said in the city's announcement, and he told reporters that holding more people doesn't make the city safer. Council Speaker Julie Menin said delays under past mayors made clear that "more time is needed" to keep the Council's 2019 promise.
Supporters also say a lower jail count is realistic. Vincent Schiraldi, correction commissioner under Mayor Bill de Blasio, said crime has trended down for decades and asked why the government should spend billions just in case it rises. It has been done elsewhere: New Orleans cut its jail population by more than two-thirds in the decade after Hurricane Katrina.
The case for caution
Some who know the system well doubt the numbers will hold. Elizabeth Glazer, who ran the city's criminal justice office under de Blasio, said the cut is possible but won't be easy. Even if the city hits its number, she asked, "can that be sustained for the decades when all you have is that capacity?" She wants a backup plan, including possibly building again on the island.
In a New York Times essay days before the plan came out, Glazer argued the city should renovate Rikers jails into safer buildings while the new ones go up, City & State reported. The doubts go back further. Former Mayor Eric Adams opposed the borough jails and federal oversight.
How coverage differs
Three of the four right-leaning outlets led with the five-year delay, and two gave the $16 billion price of the new jails. None of the left-leaning or center reports we read told readers what the jails cost.
If you read the left 7 of 13 outlets
Deaths and doubts set the scene.
If you read the center 2 of 9 outlets
The plan arrived without its critics.
If you read the right 5 of 12 outlets
The five-year slip was the headline.
Sources
Left
7 of 13 left-leaning outlets we track reported this
- NPR: New York City unveils a bold plan to move its jails off Rikers Island, Nov. 20
- The Guardian: Zohran Mamdani unveils plan to close Rikers Island jail complex, Nov. 20
- Associated Press (via KKTV): Mamdani sets plan to close NYC's notorious Rikers Island jail, Nov. 20
- Politico: Mamdani releases long-awaited plan to close Rikers Island, Nov. 20 (headline only; text unavailable)
Center
2 of 9 center outlets we track reported this
Right
5 of 12 right-leaning outlets we track reported this
- New York Post: Mamdani sets out plan to close Rikers, but proposes delaying deadline by 5 years, Nov. 20
- The Daily Wire: Mamdani's plan to close Rikers comes with a dangerous catch, Nov. 20
- The National Desk: Mamdani unveils plan to close Rikers by 2032, more than 5 years past legal deadline, Nov. 20
- Fox News: NYC Mayor Mamdani announces delayed plan to close city's largest jail, Nov. 20
Other reporting
Primary
- NYC Mayor's Office: Mayor Mamdani releases city's first comprehensive plan to close Rikers Island, Nov. 20 · Archived copy
- City of New York: The Close Rikers Strategic Plan, Nov. 20 · Archived copy
- City of New York: Close Rikers plan summary and timeline · Archived copy
- New York City Council: Int. 1592-A, enacted as Local Law 16 of 2021, transfer of Rikers Island · Archived copy
This article was produced by AI under our Editorial Standards. Corrections are reviewed before they go live.
How coverage differs
Free with a Fair Witness account
See how left, center and right covered this story
A free account shows where the coverage agrees and where it splits, what each side played up and played down, and, when one side's outlets missed a story, who missed it.
Keep reading
The newest stories in U.S., then the rest of the site.
Newest · U.S.
ICE arrests two passengers on a Seattle airport jet bridge as they board a flight
Washington's governor said he believes the masked officers broke a new state law, but that law's only penalty is a lawsuit by the people detained.
Latest
New stories and updates, newest first. Times are Eastern.
-
Nov 22
12:13 AMTop story U.S.
ICE arrests two passengers on a Seattle airport jet bridge as they board a flight
Washington's governor said he believes the masked officers broke a new state law, but that law's only penalty is a lawsuit by the people detained.
-
Nov 21
6:12 PMNew Economy
Trump says he would work with Democrats on a 10% credit card interest rate cap
The president and Sen. Elizabeth Warren now back a cap that banks and some Republican senators oppose, and no bill has moved yet.
-
Nov 21
5:19 PMUpdated Health
US loses measles elimination status after 26 years, PAHO says
The finding that measles spreads here again means the U.S. must now stop the spread for a full year to win the status back.
Spin Meter: how each side framed it · 4/5 -
Nov 21
5:17 PMUpdated World
Mexico captures 'El Chapo Isidro,' an FBI Ten Most Wanted fugitive, in Sinaloa raid
U.S. prosecutors charged him in 2012, and Mexico has not yet said whether it will send him north to face those charges.
-
Nov 21
2:55 PMUpdated U.S.
House Democrats seek Cantor Fitzgerald's Nvidia records in Lutnick probe
The letter shows how the House's incoming Democratic chairs plan to test whether Lutnick's handling of Megaspeed was shaped by his family firm's Nvidia stake.
-
Nov 21
11:50 PMUpdated U.S.
Trump orders federal contractors to check with White House before answering Congress
The order gives the White House a say in what companies doing government work tell Congress, weeks before Democrats take charge and start investigating.
-
Nov 21
11:14 PMUpdated Science
COP31 climate talks run into overtime after draft drops fossil fuels
Whether the year's climate deal names oil, gas and coal at all now rests on a consensus rule that lets one country block it.
Out of Frame · Right
-
Nov 21
11:12 PMUpdated Science
BepiColombo enters Mercury orbit, only the second mission to circle the planet
After an eight-year trip and a year's delay, two orbiters are set to study a planet that only NASA had circled before.
-
Nov 21
8:52 PMUpdated U.S.
Storm that flooded Florida heads up the East Coast as Thanksgiving week nears
Wind, rain and coastal flooding could reach the Carolinas Saturday and New England by Sunday night, and forecasters see another East Coast storm around Thanksgiving.
-
Nov 21
8:37 PMUpdated U.S.
Cornyn blocks Elliot Gaiser, Trump's pick for a Dallas federal court seat
A Texas senator's veto can stop a lifetime judgeship, and Republicans have until Jan. 3 to fill the seat before Democrats run the Senate.
-
Nov 21
8:36 PMUpdated World
Russian missile crashes in Poland as strikes hit three Kyiv bridges
Poland called the crash a likely intentional provocation during allied drills, and NATO's treaty leaves each ally to decide how to respond.
Edge of Frame · Right
-
Nov 21
8:19 PMUpdated Technology
FBI investigating apparent breach of its national crime database, CNN and NBC report
Police across the country run warrant and gun checks on the system, and it is the second federal breach reported in a day.
-
Nov 21
8:18 PMUpdated U.S.
Katie Zacharia faces California State Bar investigation over lawyer claims
The case tests whether California's law making it a crime to claim you can practice law without a license reaches a TV commentator.
The Fair Witness Daily
Get each morning's Spin Meter in your inbox
The Daily leads with the Spin Meter, then the day's explainers. A free account also unlocks every Spin Meter on the site.
Free. Unsubscribe anytime. Already a member? Sign in