Judge rules Brooke Rollins's religious emails to USDA staff likely unconstitutional
The order holds Agriculture Secretary Brooke Rollins to the same limits on faith at work that her department set for its own staff.
Judge Trina Thompson's Nov. 19 order found that two of Rollins's holiday messages to USDA staff went too far. Document: U.S. District Court, Northern District of California; photos: U.S. District Court, Northern District of California / Public domain (left), Christophe Paul / USDA / Public domain (right); graphic: Fair Witness
Who covered this
On this page · sections
The short version
- A federal judge ruled that Agriculture Secretary Brooke Rollins's Christmas and Easter emails to USDA staff likely violated the First Amendment.
- The order holds a Cabinet secretary to her own department's limits on religious expression, for USDA workers who are expected to read her emails.
- USDA says it is considering an appeal, and the next court date in the case is Dec. 17.
Documents in this story · 2
A federal judge ordered Agriculture Secretary Brooke Rollins on Thursday to follow her own department's limits on faith at work, ruling that her religious emails to all USDA employees likely broke the First Amendment.
U.S. District Judge Trina Thompson's order holds while the lawsuit goes on. It turns on two messages: a Christmas video Rollins sent staff in December 2025 and an Easter email in April. Thompson found these two went past holiday wishes into pressure to share her faith. USDA says it is thinking about an appeal. The ruling lands five weeks before Christmas, the holiday behind one of those two messages.
Why it matters to you
If you work for the federal government, this ruling tests how far your boss's boss can go in sharing faith with you over work email. The order covers the U.S. Department of Agriculture, which the court says has about 100,000 people. Politico put the number at roughly 70,000.
The ruling draws a line between two kinds of speech. The judge said she takes no view on what Rollins does as a private person. What she limited is the work email, the same one Rollins uses for news about office moves, job changes and shutdown plans. Staff are expected to read that inbox. For now, the order keeps messages like her Christmas and Easter notes out of it.
What the ruling on Brooke Rollins's religious emails allows
Thompson did not ban Rollins from mentioning God, and she wrote that her ruling "says nothing about the value of prayer" or those who believe in it. The order sets three limits. Rollins must stop if a coworker asks her to. She cannot make the workplace hostile by pushing her faith on people who don't want it. And she cannot use her power to pressure the people who work for her. She may still say why her faith matters to her, invite coworkers to services and share her views when the talk turns that way.
Several reports went further. Politico said the judge ordered her to stop sending Christian emails, and the New York Post said she was barred from sending Christian messages. The order's binding words are narrower than that. Still, another part of it says the court must stop emails like the two it found unlawful from going out, because USDA gives staff no way to opt out.
The judge also narrowed the employees' case. She threw out their claims under the Administrative Procedure Act, the law on how agencies make rules, because a holiday email is not an official agency rule or order. Only the constitutional claim goes forward.
Why the judge used Rollins's own memo
The 21-page order borrows its rules from Rollins herself. Every limit the judge put on Rollins is quoted from a memo on faith at work that Rollins's own USDA issued on Nov. 20, 2025, the order shows. Under that memo, the judge wrote, a regular employee likely couldn't send an unwanted email to all staff urging them to fast for Ramadan or go to a synagogue. Then she asked, "Why should the Secretary be exempt from her own rules?"
Rollins's lawyers had pointed to the same memo, for the opposite reason. In an August filing, Justice Department lawyers cited it to show that all USDA employees have broad rights to their own faith at work. So, they argued, the workers had no real reason to fear for their jobs.
Thompson based her finding on three things: Rollins's rank, her use of a work account to reach every employee, and wording the judge said pushed others out. The Easter email compared staff to "the very first disciples to encounter our risen Lord in the Upper Room". Its use of words like our and us, Thompson wrote, assumed every reader shared Rollins's Christian beliefs. She set the case against the Supreme Court's 2022 ruling for a football coach who prayed after games, whose prayers were not aimed at a captive audience.
How the dispute over Rollins's emails began
Starting with July 4, 2025, Rollins sent holiday messages to the whole department from her official account, the order recounts. Her Independence Day and Thanksgiving notes mentioned God, but the judge's finding covered only the Christmas and Easter messages. The Christmas video spoke of "the gift of his Son and our Savior Jesus Christ". The Easter email opened with a drawing of the empty tomb.
The National Federation of Federal Employees, a federal workers' union that represents more than 19,000 USDA employees, sued in May with six employees. (The New York Post and Fox News counted seven employees.) They include a Buddhist, an atheist and a Pagan who said they felt pressure to hide their beliefs. The complaint said supervisors warned that speaking up would bring "trouble."
Rollins answered the lawsuit on social media. "It's just another opportunity to remind everyone: He is Risen," she wrote on X, Fox News reported. Her department said it would keep the plaintiffs in its prayers. The employees asked for the injunction on July 22, and Thompson heard arguments on Oct. 27.
Why should the Secretary be exempt from her own rules?
What we don't know yet
USDA hasn't said whether it will appeal, only that it is weighing one. An appeal would go to the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit, which could pause the order or leave it in place while it decides.
Nor is it clear whether Rollins will send a Christmas message to staff this year, or how the court would judge one. The order names only the April and December messages as going too far, and it faults them for going beyond mere holiday wishes, which leaves open what a plainer greeting would mean.
The judge set a case management conference for Dec. 17, with a joint statement from both sides due Dec. 10. That is the next date when the court will hear how each side plans to proceed.
The case each side makes
The employees: a captive audience
The employees and their lawyers argue that an email from the head of your agency is not something you can skip. Those messages carry news about jobs, moves and time off, so staff must read them. A religious message in the same inbox puts quiet pressure on anyone who doesn't share it. They say the secretary never marked the holidays of other faiths, which left non-Christian workers feeling like outsiders.
Rachel Laser, president of Americans United for Separation of Church and State, which represents the employees, said the ruling should tell the Trump administration that it "cannot misuse taxpayer resources to preach." Randy Erwin, the union's president, called it a victory for the First Amendment. One plaintiff, USDA employee Ashley Miller, said coming forward had been frightening but would help everyone at the department.
Rollins and USDA: a holiday greeting is not coercion
USDA argues that Rollins did what American leaders have done since George Washington: call on God on national holidays. "The Constitution does not mandate secularism in government affairs," its lawyers wrote in August, citing Washington's 1789 Thanksgiving proclamation and Lincoln's second inaugural address. The emails asked no one to do anything, they argued. Staff could tell from the subject lines that the messages weren't about work, and delete them.
The department says offense is not the same as coercion, and that Rollins was sharing her personal reasons for celebrating. After the ruling, USDA called it an "unprecedented attempt to muzzle a Cabinet Secretary," the New York Post reported.
How coverage differs
Of the reports below, only the New York Post's said USDA may appeal. Headlines also split on how far the order goes: The Hill's "likely violated" matches the ruling, while others said Rollins was barred or blocked.
If you read the left 6 of 13 outlets
The plaintiffs had the floor.
If you read the center 2 of 9 outlets
The law came with a wider fight.
If you read the right 2 of 12 outlets
USDA's reply reached you, via the Post.
Sources
Left
6 of 13 left-leaning outlets we track reported this
- USA Today: Judge says USDA Secretary Brooke Rollins' religious emails 'go too far', Nov. 19
- Associated Press, via The Guardian: Religious messages agriculture secretary emailed to staff deemed unconstitutional, Nov. 19
- Politico: Federal judge blocks USDA secretary's Christian notes to agency workers, Nov. 19
Center
2 of 9 center outlets we track reported this
Right
2 of 12 right-leaning outlets we track reported this
- New York Post: USDA boss Brooke Rollins barred from sending Christian messages to federal workers, Nov. 20
- The Washington Times: Judge orders Agriculture secretary to cool it with Christmas, Easter messages, Nov. 19
- Fox News: Federal employees accuse USDA secretary of 'Christian proselytizing' in holiday emails to staff, May 14
This article was produced by AI under our Editorial Standards. Corrections are reviewed before they go live.
How coverage differs
Free with a Fair Witness account
See how left, center and right covered this story
A free account shows where the coverage agrees and where it splits, what each side played up and played down, and, when one side's outlets missed a story, who missed it.
Keep reading
The newest stories in U.S., then the rest of the site.
Newest · U.S.
ICE arrests two passengers on a Seattle airport jet bridge as they board a flight
Washington's governor said he believes the masked officers broke a new state law, but that law's only penalty is a lawsuit by the people detained.
Latest
New stories and updates, newest first. Times are Eastern.
-
Nov 22
12:13 AMTop story U.S.
ICE arrests two passengers on a Seattle airport jet bridge as they board a flight
Washington's governor said he believes the masked officers broke a new state law, but that law's only penalty is a lawsuit by the people detained.
-
Nov 21
6:12 PMNew Economy
Trump says he would work with Democrats on a 10% credit card interest rate cap
The president and Sen. Elizabeth Warren now back a cap that banks and some Republican senators oppose, and no bill has moved yet.
-
Nov 21
5:19 PMUpdated Health
US loses measles elimination status after 26 years, PAHO says
The finding that measles spreads here again means the U.S. must now stop the spread for a full year to win the status back.
Spin Meter: how each side framed it · 4/5 -
Nov 21
5:17 PMUpdated World
Mexico captures 'El Chapo Isidro,' an FBI Ten Most Wanted fugitive, in Sinaloa raid
U.S. prosecutors charged him in 2012, and Mexico has not yet said whether it will send him north to face those charges.
-
Nov 21
2:55 PMUpdated U.S.
House Democrats seek Cantor Fitzgerald's Nvidia records in Lutnick probe
The letter shows how the House's incoming Democratic chairs plan to test whether Lutnick's handling of Megaspeed was shaped by his family firm's Nvidia stake.
-
Nov 21
11:50 PMUpdated U.S.
Trump orders federal contractors to check with White House before answering Congress
The order gives the White House a say in what companies doing government work tell Congress, weeks before Democrats take charge and start investigating.
-
Nov 21
11:14 PMUpdated Science
COP31 climate talks run into overtime after draft drops fossil fuels
Whether the year's climate deal names oil, gas and coal at all now rests on a consensus rule that lets one country block it.
Out of Frame · Right
-
Nov 21
11:12 PMUpdated Science
BepiColombo enters Mercury orbit, only the second mission to circle the planet
After an eight-year trip and a year's delay, two orbiters are set to study a planet that only NASA had circled before.
-
Nov 21
8:52 PMUpdated U.S.
Storm that flooded Florida heads up the East Coast as Thanksgiving week nears
Wind, rain and coastal flooding could reach the Carolinas Saturday and New England by Sunday night, and forecasters see another East Coast storm around Thanksgiving.
-
Nov 21
8:37 PMUpdated U.S.
Cornyn blocks Elliot Gaiser, Trump's pick for a Dallas federal court seat
A Texas senator's veto can stop a lifetime judgeship, and Republicans have until Jan. 3 to fill the seat before Democrats run the Senate.
-
Nov 21
8:36 PMUpdated World
Russian missile crashes in Poland as strikes hit three Kyiv bridges
Poland called the crash a likely intentional provocation during allied drills, and NATO's treaty leaves each ally to decide how to respond.
Edge of Frame · Right
-
Nov 21
8:19 PMUpdated Technology
FBI investigating apparent breach of its national crime database, CNN and NBC report
Police across the country run warrant and gun checks on the system, and it is the second federal breach reported in a day.
-
Nov 21
8:18 PMUpdated U.S.
Katie Zacharia faces California State Bar investigation over lawyer claims
The case tests whether California's law making it a crime to claim you can practice law without a license reaches a TV commentator.
The Fair Witness Daily
Get each morning's Spin Meter in your inbox
The Daily leads with the Spin Meter, then the day's explainers. A free account also unlocks every Spin Meter on the site.
Free. Unsubscribe anytime. Already a member? Sign in