Skip to content
San Quentin State Prison on the shore of San Francisco Bay, seen from the water

U.S.

Edge of Frame · Center

Trump calls Newsom's plan to commute California's 548 death sentences a 'disaster'

The president wants the clemency overturned, but the decision on most of it now sits with California's Supreme Court, which has refused a governor before.

Published 8 min read

San Quentin State Prison, where California held its condemned men until they were moved to other prisons. Photo, January 2022: Sarah Stierch (Missvain) / Wikimedia Commons / CC BY 4.0

Who covered this

How we flag these

The short version

  • President Trump called Gov. Gavin Newsom's plan to commute all 548 California death sentences a disaster for justice and said he hopes it is overturned.
  • Most of the commutations can't take effect unless California's Supreme Court recommends them, and victims' advocates have promised to fight them there.
  • Newsom has asked the court to act by the end of the year, before he leaves office in January.
Documents in this story · 2
  • LetterOpen letter regarding commutation of all death sentencesGov. Gavin Newsom · PDF · Nov. 5, 2026Original Archived
  • RecordDonald Trump on Truth Social, Nov. 14, 9:54 a.m. ETtruthsocial.com · Web pageOpen Archived

President Donald Trump on Saturday called California Gov. Gavin Newsom's plan to commute all 548 of the state's death sentences "a disaster for Justice in America," and said he hopes it is overturned.

It was the president's first public word on Newsom's Nov. 5 decision to turn every death sentence in California into life in prison without parole. The next move isn't his, though. For 382 of the 548 people, the commutations can't take effect unless California's own Supreme Court recommends them, and victims' advocates are preparing to fight them there, Newsweek reported.

Why it matters to you

If you live in California, this is about a punishment voters have chosen to keep. They rejected repeal measures in 2012 and 2016, yet the state hasn't executed anyone since January 2006, according to Newsweek. Newsom's move doesn't repeal the law. Prosecutors can still seek death in new cases, and no one would be freed, pardoned or made eligible for parole.

For the rest of the country, the scale matters. California holds the largest death row in the Western Hemisphere, Newsom wrote. If the court approves, it would be the largest mass commutation of death sentences in U.S. history and would shrink the national death-row population by nearly 30%, Newsweek reported. Newsom has asked the court to decide by the end of the year.

What Trump said about the death row commutations

Trump posted at about 10 a.m. ET Saturday on Truth Social. He called Newsom incompetent and insensitive, said some of the inmates had killed again and again, and wrote that victims' relatives are right to be devastated. He put the number of inmates at 563. Newsom's office counts 548, a gap Newsweek pointed out. Of those, 529 are men and 19 are women. We found no public response from Newsom's office to Trump's post as of 3:10 p.m. ET Sunday; Newsweek and the New York Post said they had asked for comment.

The post didn't say who might overturn the decision. Attorney General Todd Blanche had already weighed in on Thursday. He called the move unfortunate and compared it to President Joe Biden's December 2024 commutation of 37 of the 40 people on federal death row, Newsweek reported. Blanche also said that state law differs and that most governors hold clemency power.

That leaves the fight in California. On Thursday, families of murder victims and prosecutors from across the state joined the Criminal Justice Legal Foundation, a victims' rights legal group. Together they said they would bring every legal challenge they could before the state Supreme Court. Los Angeles County District Attorney Nathan Hochman said his office would join them, calling it "this arbitrary commutation that sidelines victims' families," according to Newsweek.

Why the state Supreme Court has the final word

California's constitution lets a governor commute a sentence. But for anyone convicted of more than one felony, the governor needs the state Supreme Court's recommendation, as Newsom's letter notes, with at least four of its seven justices agreeing. That covers 382 people on death row. The remaining 166 don't need the court, by Newsweek's count.

For most of a century, the court approved what governors asked. Then, in the last days of Gov. Jerry Brown's term in 2018, the court rejected 10 of his clemency requests. They were its first refusals of a governor since 1930, the ABA Journal reported, and the court didn't explain them.

Earlier that year, the court had set out its role. It said it doesn't judge whether clemency is wise, only whether granting it would be an abuse of the governor's power, as the appellate law firm Horvitz & Levy summarized. It has never had to consider a blanket commutation like this one, a retired research attorney for the court wrote in 2024. Newsom's letter says he is confident the plan fits California law, and says the justices may personally disagree with it.

How Newsom got here

Newsom's clemency is the second half of a plan he started in his first months in office. On March 13, 2019, he halted executions with a moratorium, which left every death sentence in place, his letter says. Trump objected then, too. "Defying voters," he wrote on Twitter that morning, Fox News reported.

In his Nov. 5 letter, Newsom said he weighed commuting only some sentences and decided against it. Separating crimes, he wrote, would create two classes of murder victims. The men have already been moved off San Quentin's death row and spread across 24 other prisons, CalMatters reported. Newsom's term ends in January, and Gov.-elect Xavier Becerra has committed to keeping the moratorium.

a disaster for Justice in America

President Donald Trump, on Truth Social, Nov. 14 (post)

What we don't know yet

We don't know when California's Supreme Court will act on the 382 commutations that need its recommendation, or whether it will weigh them one by one or as a group. If the court waits or turns some down, those people stay under death sentences, though Becerra has said he would keep the moratorium that bars executions.

It also isn't clear what the Criminal Justice Legal Foundation will file, or when, or whether and how Newsom will answer Trump.

The case each side makes

Opponents: voters and juries already decided

Critics say a single governor has set aside hundreds of verdicts that juries reached and voters chose to keep. Trump's post centers the families of victims, and Hochman says his prosecutors promised those families the law would run its course, Newsweek reported. Faye Jenkins, whose daughter and son-in-law were murdered in 2008, told reporters that voters had backed the death penalty and Newsom shouldn't have stepped in, NBC News reported.

Some go further and argue that life without parole may not mean what it says. Orange County District Attorney Todd Spitzer said such prisoners do get out, NBC News reported. "Life without the possibility of parole is absolute nonsense," he said. Stan Goldman, a law professor at Loyola Marymount University, said that, as a practical matter, it isn't a real problem. Newsom's office has said these prisoners aren't eligible for new state parole rules, Fox News reported.

Newsom and supporters: a system that has failed

Newsom hasn't responded to Trump's post. He made his case in his Nov. 5 letter, before it. He wrote that the state can't fairly carry out the death penalty and shouldn't try. The letter calls the system a failure that has convicted innocent people and left some cases in the courts for more than 40 years. It describes life without parole as the harshest sentence the state can ethically enforce. "These offenders will die in prison but not by our hand," he wrote.

Supporters also make their case in victims' terms. Natasha Minsker of the California Anti-Death Penalty Coalition told CBS Sacramento that the death penalty doesn't help victims heal. Polly Klaas's sister, Jess Nichol, said the same, according to CalMatters. Newsom wrote that he respects families who disagree and that the decision will anger and hurt some Californians.

Sources

Center

1 of 9 center outlets we track reported this

Checked, no report found as of 2:40 p.m. ET Nov. 15: Reuters, The Hill, BBC News, The Christian Science Monitor, UPI, NewsNation, +2.

This article was produced by AI under our Editorial Standards. Corrections are reviewed before they go live.

Challenge this article

How coverage differs

Free with a Fair Witness account

See how left, center and right covered this story

A free account shows where the coverage agrees and where it splits, what each side played up and played down, and, when one side's outlets missed a story, who missed it.

Share this story

Challenge this article

Found a factual error? Send us published evidence. We review every submission and correct errors in public.

Keep reading

The newest stories in U.S., then the rest of the site.

Newest · U.S.

House Democrats seek Cantor Fitzgerald's Nvidia records in Lutnick probe

The letter shows how the House's incoming Democratic chairs plan to test whether Lutnick's handling of Megaspeed was shaped by his family firm's Nvidia stake.

· 6 min read

The Democrats' Nov. 17 letter asks whether Lutnick's export decisions were shaped by his family firm's holdings. Document: House Judiciary Committee Democrats; graphic: Fair Witness

Latest

New stories and updates, newest first. Times are Eastern.

All updates
  1. Nov 18

    3:08 PMTop story U.S.

    House Democrats seek Cantor Fitzgerald's Nvidia records in Lutnick probe

    The letter shows how the House's incoming Democratic chairs plan to test whether Lutnick's handling of Megaspeed was shaped by his family firm's Nvidia stake.

  2. Nov 18

    11:40 AMUpdated World

    U.S. strikes Iran's Qeshm Island after third Iranian attack on Bahrain, officials say

    It is the U.S. reply to Iranian attacks that ended a two-month lull, and Iran's next move will show whether the exchange keeps going.

  3. Nov 18

    11:39 AMUpdated U.S.

    White House counsel warns Oversight Democrats their probes could be criminal

    The letter escalates a fight over how far Congress can dig into the Trump administration once Democrats take over in January.

  4. Nov 18

    11:14 AMUpdated World

    Trump will meet Xi and Putin together Thursday to discuss nuclear arms, White House says

    No treaty has capped the world's two largest nuclear arsenals since February, and Trump wants China in whatever replaces it.

  5. Nov 18

    11:14 AMUpdated U.S.

    NSA's classified network goes down; White House says no sign of a cyberattack

    The intelligence agency's internal system for sharing secrets failed in a week of U.S. tech outages, and Democrats want a briefing.

  6. Nov 18

    2:55 PMUpdated World

    Part of Crimean Bridge collapses after Ukrainian strike as Russia hits Kyiv's bridges

    Each side hit bridges it calls military routes, two days before Trump meets Putin and Xi in China.

  7. Nov 18

    2:37 PMUpdated U.S.

    Bessent blames Lutnick's Commerce Department for not blacklisting Megaspeed

    The Cabinet split over a chip buyer tied to the Nvidia scandal is a fight over how well the U.S. keeps advanced chips from China.

  8. Nov 18

    2:16 PMUpdated U.S.

    Mullin defends flying government plane to LSU-Texas game a day after FAA ground stop

    His department says he paid his way, but federal rules can set that at a coach fare, and no one has said what he paid.

  9. Nov 18

    2:15 PMUpdated World

    Iran fires on U.S. air base in Kuwait and at Bahrain after U.S. strike on Qeshm

    Iran's first attack on Kuwait in two months widens a weeklong exchange of fire, and Washington has not said how it will answer.

  10. Nov 18

    12:41 PMNew World

    Britain hands Army officer accused of spying for Russia to U.S. military

    The handover moves any prosecution to the United States, where officials have not said whether a military or civilian court would hear it.

    Edge of Frame · Right

  11. Nov 18

    12:30 PMTop story U.S.

    Garcia tells Vance, Trump's sons and others to preserve records for House probes

    The letters map what Democrats plan to investigate once they take the House in January and gain the power to subpoena.

  12. Nov 18

    12:25 PMTop story U.S.

    House Democrats nominate Hakeem Jeffries for speaker, 251-11, ahead of Jan. 3 vote

    Eleven Democrats voted no in a count he asked for. His party's projected majority lets him lose almost 40 votes and still reach 218.

  13. Nov 18

    11:53 AMUpdated World

    US Army soldier arrested in UK on suspicion of spying for Russia

    The soldier, who has not been named or charged, was assigned to a NATO headquarters built to respond quickly to crises.

The Fair Witness Daily

Get each morning's Spin Meter in your inbox

The Daily leads with the Spin Meter, then the day's explainers. A free account also unlocks every Spin Meter on the site.

Check your inbox to confirm your subscription.

Free. Unsubscribe anytime. Already a member? Sign in