Skip to content
Justice Clarence Thomas, seated in an armchair on a stage at the Library of Congress, speaks and gestures with both hands

U.S.

Supreme Court won't hear challenge to Maryland's 'sensitive places' gun law

Maryland's limits on where permit holders may carry stay in force, but Justice Thomas invited a narrower challenge to laws like it.

Published 8 min read

Justice Clarence Thomas, who wrote Monday's statement on the Maryland gun case, speaks at the Library of Congress in 2012. Photo, September 2012: Earl McDonald / National Archives / Public domain

Who covered this

What these mean

The short version

  • The Supreme Court on Monday refused to hear a challenge to Maryland's ban on guns in places such as parks, bars, hospitals and transit.
  • The ban stays in force, though Justice Clarence Thomas wrote that he doubts many laws like it can survive the court's history test.
  • Thomas invited a narrower case, and a New Jersey ruling set for rehearing by a full appeals court could shape the next appeal.
Documents in this story · 5
  • RulingSupreme Court order list, Nov. 16, 2026, with Justice Thomas's statement in Novotny v. Moore, No. 25-1324supremecourt.gov · PDFOriginal Archived
  • RulingSupreme Court docket No. 25-1324, Novotny v. Mooresupremecourt.gov · Web pageOpen Archived
  • RulingStatement on Supreme Court decision leaving gun safety protections in placeMaryland Attorney General Anthony Brown · Web page · Nov. 17, 2026Open Archived
  • RulingBrief in opposition, Maryland Attorney General Anthony Brownsupremecourt.gov · PDF · Aug. 17, 2026Original Archived
  • RulingU.S. Court of Appeals for the 4th Circuit, Kipke v. Moore, decided Jan. 20, 2026ca4.uscourts.gov · PDFOriginal Archived

The Supreme Court on Monday refused to hear a challenge to Maryland's "sensitive places" gun law, leaving in force the state's bans on carrying guns in parks, bars and hospitals and on public transit.

The order was a single line, but Justice Clarence Thomas added a four-page statement. He agreed the court should pass on this case, because it challenged so many different places at once. He also wrote that he is skeptical that each of the laws fits the nation's history of gun rules, and that the court should take up a narrower case. That leaves gun owners and states with a law that stands today and a clear hint about where the next fight may land.

Why it matters to you

Nothing changes for now for anyone with a Maryland carry permit. Permit holders still may not carry a gun at a public demonstration, on mass transit, in places of amusement or in health care facilities. The same goes for places that serve alcohol on site and tens of thousands of acres of state park and forest land.

The case also reaches past Maryland. California, New York, New Jersey and Hawaii have similarly broad restrictions, NBC News reported. By turning the case away, the justices left those states' lists in place too, for now. Thomas spoke only for himself, but his statement points gun-rights lawyers toward a challenge to particular places, such as bars or parks, rather than a whole list.

What the court did, and what Thomas wrote

The case, Novotny v. Moore, joined two lawsuits by Maryland gun owners and gun-rights groups. Among the groups are the Second Amendment Foundation, the Firearms Policy Coalition and Maryland Shall Issue, along with the state's National Rifle Association affiliate. The docket shows the justices put off the petition three times before taking it up at their private conferences on Nov. 6 and Nov. 13.

Thomas's statement explains his vote. Each Maryland law rests on a different history of gun rules, he wrote, so taking them all at once would make the court's review harder. He then listed laws in other states that he doubts can pass the history test: New Jersey's bans at zoos, libraries and state beaches, New York's 20 listed locations and California's 29 gun-free places. "These restrictions stand on questionable historical ground," he wrote.

What his statement was not matters too. It was a statement, not a dissent, and no other justice joined it. No justice recorded a vote to hear the case. The same order list shows how that looks when it happens: in an unrelated California case, Justice Neil Gorsuch said he would grant review and Thomas wrote a dissent that Justice Samuel Alito joined.

How Maryland's "sensitive places" law reached the Supreme Court

The fight began with the court's own 2022 ruling in New York State Rifle & Pistol Association v. Bruen. That decision found for the first time that the Second Amendment protects a right to carry a handgun in public, and it set a new test: a gun law must be consistent with the nation's historical tradition of gun regulation. Thomas wrote that majority opinion.

Bruen ended Maryland's strict rules on who could get a carry permit, so the state, like several others, turned to limits on where permit holders could carry. Maryland's version, signed by Gov. Wes Moore in 2023, added colleges, hospitals, power plants, amusement parks and places selling alcohol or cannabis to older bans at schools, transit and protests. Gun owners sued the day it was signed, targeting 10 categories of places.

A federal trial judge upheld most of the limits but ruled against the bans at demonstrations and at places that serve alcohol. The U.S. Court of Appeals for the 4th Circuit, in Richmond, Virginia, then went further. Its January ruling upheld every challenged place except private property open to the public, where Maryland had barred guns unless the owner allowed them. That one rule is gone, and it was not part of this appeal. In June, the Supreme Court struck down a similar Hawaii rule in a 6-3 decision.

A split ruling left standing

The appeals court decision the justices left in place was closer than its outcome suggests. Of the bans it upheld, the three judges agreed only on those in government buildings, schools and health care facilities, according to the 4th Circuit's opinion. On transit, demonstrations, state parks and forests, museums, stadiums and casinos, and places that sell alcohol, the vote was 2-1, with Judge Agee in dissent each time. Those are most of the places the case was about.

That split lines up with Thomas's point. Two of the places the judges all accepted, schools and government buildings, are on the short list the Supreme Court said in 2008 was not in doubt. None of the places where they split is on that list. Neither are the examples Thomas chose from other states, from zoos to state beaches.

These restrictions stand on questionable historical ground.

Justice Clarence Thomas, statement respecting the denial of review, Nov. 16 (order list)

What we don't know yet

It is not yet clear which narrower sensitive-places challenge, the kind Justice Thomas urged, will reach the Supreme Court next, or when. In New Jersey, a ruling that upheld many of that state's sensitive-place limits was vacated so the full appeals court could rehear it, and its outcome could shape the next appeal.

We also don't know how many of his colleagues share his doubts. Thomas spoke only for himself, and the court gave no reason for its denial.

The case each side makes

The gun owners and gun-rights groups

The challengers say Maryland used the word "sensitive" to undo what the Supreme Court decided in 2022. After it was forced to issue carry permits, the state listed so many places that a permit holder's ability to carry in public at all is severely limited, they argue. "Maryland simply made those permits useless everywhere," Adam Kraut, executive director of the Second Amendment Foundation, said in a statement.

Their own test is narrow. The only historical exceptions, they say, were places where the state provides its own security, such as courthouses. The nation's founders would have been shocked by a broad ban on guns in crowded places, they argue, according to the Washington Times account of their filings. They also asked the court to step in because lower courts have upheld similar laws for different reasons and for different kinds of places.

Maryland

Brown called the order a victory for public safety in a statement Tuesday and said his office would keep defending the laws. Brown's office argues that each ban fits a long American tradition of keeping guns out of crowded places. In an August brief asking the court not to take the case, the state said any split among appeals courts is minor and outweighed by "vast areas of shared consensus" (brief in opposition). Lower courts should keep working the issue before the justices weigh in, it said.

The state also points to old laws, not only new ones. It cited laws from New Orleans in 1817 and New Mexico in 1853 barring guns at public ballrooms, and an 1870 Texas law on churches and schoolrooms, the Washington Times reported. The challengers' rule that a place counts only if armed guards protect it, the brief says, would turn the history test into a judgment about today's security budgets.

Sources

This article was produced by AI under our Editorial Standards. Corrections are reviewed before they go live.

Challenge this article

How coverage differs

Free with a Fair Witness account

See how left, center and right covered this story

A free account shows where the coverage agrees and where it splits, what each side played up and played down, and, when one side's outlets missed a story, who missed it.

Share this story

Challenge this article

Found a factual error? Send us published evidence. We review every submission and correct errors in public.

Keep reading

The newest stories in U.S., then the rest of the site.

Newest · U.S.

House Democrats seek Cantor Fitzgerald's Nvidia records in Lutnick probe

The letter shows how the House's incoming Democratic chairs plan to test whether Lutnick's handling of Megaspeed was shaped by his family firm's Nvidia stake.

· 6 min read

The Democrats' Nov. 17 letter asks whether Lutnick's export decisions were shaped by his family firm's holdings. Document: House Judiciary Committee Democrats; graphic: Fair Witness

Latest

New stories and updates, newest first. Times are Eastern.

All updates
  1. Nov 18

    2:55 PMUpdated World

    Part of Crimean Bridge collapses after Ukrainian strike as Russia hits Kyiv's bridges

    Each side hit bridges it calls military routes, two days before Trump meets Putin and Xi in China.

  2. Nov 18

    11:14 AMUpdated World

    Trump will meet Xi and Putin together Thursday to discuss nuclear arms, White House says

    No treaty has capped the world's two largest nuclear arsenals since February, and Trump wants China in whatever replaces it.

  3. Nov 18

    11:14 AMUpdated U.S.

    NSA's classified network goes down; White House says no sign of a cyberattack

    The intelligence agency's internal system for sharing secrets failed in a week of U.S. tech outages, and Democrats want a briefing.

  4. Nov 18

    11:14 AMUpdated Technology

    Apple outage: company says an internal update hit iCloud, Apple Pay and App Store

    Many services were back by afternoon, but Apple's status page for app makers still listed key tools as down Tuesday evening.

  5. Nov 18

    9:15 AMNew Culture

    Pope Leo says no to married priests for now, details his lung cancer surgery

    His answer keeps on hold a 2019 proposal from Amazon bishops to make married deacons priests where communities wait years for one.

  6. Nov 18

    2:16 PMUpdated U.S.

    Mullin defends flying government plane to LSU-Texas game a day after FAA ground stop

    His department says he paid his way, but federal rules can set that at a coach fare, and no one has said what he paid.

  7. Nov 18

    2:15 PMUpdated World

    Iran fires on U.S. air base in Kuwait and at Bahrain after U.S. strike on Qeshm

    Iran's first attack on Kuwait in two months widens a weeklong exchange of fire, and Washington has not said how it will answer.

  8. Nov 18

    12:41 PMNew World

    Britain hands Army officer accused of spying for Russia to U.S. military

    The handover moves any prosecution to the United States, where officials have not said whether a military or civilian court would hear it.

    Edge of Frame · Right

  9. Nov 18

    12:30 PMTop story U.S.

    Garcia tells Vance, Trump's sons and others to preserve records for House probes

    The letters map what Democrats plan to investigate once they take the House in January and gain the power to subpoena.

  10. Nov 18

    12:25 PMTop story U.S.

    House Democrats nominate Hakeem Jeffries for speaker, 251-11, ahead of Jan. 3 vote

    Eleven Democrats voted no in a count he asked for. His party's projected majority lets him lose almost 40 votes and still reach 218.

  11. Nov 18

    11:53 AMUpdated World

    US Army soldier arrested in UK on suspicion of spying for Russia

    The soldier, who has not been named or charged, was assigned to a NATO headquarters built to respond quickly to crises.

  12. Nov 18

    11:40 AMUpdated World

    U.S. strikes Iran's Qeshm Island after third Iranian attack on Bahrain, officials say

    It is the U.S. reply to Iranian attacks that ended a two-month lull, and Iran's next move will show whether the exchange keeps going.

  13. Nov 18

    11:39 AMUpdated U.S.

    White House counsel warns Oversight Democrats their probes could be criminal

    The letter escalates a fight over how far Congress can dig into the Trump administration once Democrats take over in January.

The Fair Witness Daily

Get each morning's Spin Meter in your inbox

The Daily leads with the Spin Meter, then the day's explainers. A free account also unlocks every Spin Meter on the site.

Check your inbox to confirm your subscription.

Free. Unsubscribe anytime. Already a member? Sign in