Supreme Court lets Big Bend border wall work resume in Texas
The order lets the Trump administration build in one of the border's most remote regions while a lawsuit over its environmental waivers goes on.
The Rio Grande in Big Bend National Park, part of the border sector where wall work can now resume. Photo, 2013: Glysiak / Wikimedia Commons / CC BY-SA 3.0
Who covered this
On this page · sections
Documents in this story · 3
- RulingMullin v. Friends of the Ruidosa Church, No. 26A560, order granting staySupreme Court of the United States · PDF · Nov. 9Original Archived
- RulingApplication for a stay, No. 26A560Solicitor General · PDF · Oct. 21Original Archived
- RulingOpposition to the application, No. 26A560Friends of the Ruidosa Church et al. · PDF · Oct. 29Original Archived
The Supreme Court on Monday paused a federal judge's order that had stopped Big Bend border wall construction in West Texas since early October, so work can start again.
The order does not end the lawsuit, but it decides what happens on the ground while the case goes on: the government can build, and the judge's halt is on hold. That is a setback for opponents in both parties who argue the barriers waste money and threaten the area's economy and way of life, the AP reported.
Why it matters to you
If you live in or visit far West Texas, this is about land you may know. The work covers the Big Bend Sector, which runs along more than 500 miles of the border and includes Big Bend National Park. Inside the park, plans call for about 17 miles of vehicle barriers, not the 30-foot steel wall planned elsewhere. The administration says most of the work would be on private land.
It is also about money. The government says the pause was costing it nearly half a million dollars a day. It has awarded about $7.5 billion in contracts for roads, barriers and technology in the area.
Two things are worth watching. Customs and Border Protection says it will soon release updated plans for the national park. And Texas lawmakers have filed bills to ban border structures in state parks before their next session.
What the Supreme Court decided on the Big Bend border wall
The Court's unsigned order turns on one question: could the trial judge hear the case at all? A 1996 immigration law lets the Homeland Security secretary waive all legal requirements to build border barriers quickly. It also says courts may hear only claims that the Constitution was violated, the order explains.
The challengers argued that the waivers broke the major-questions rule. That rule says agencies need clear permission from Congress before they take actions of vast economic or political weight. They called that a constitutional claim. The Court disagreed. "There is no such thing as a 'constitutional' major-questions claim," it wrote, calling it really a claim that the secretary went beyond what the law allows.
There is no such thing as a 'constitutional' major-questions claim.
The Court also weighed the harms on each side. It said the government's border security interest outweighs the harm to the scenery, recreation and environment that the challengers described.
What was the vote?
The order does not print a vote count. It notes only that Justice Ketanji Brown Jackson would have denied the request, and it gives no reason for her vote. Several outlets reported the result as 8-1, including NBC News and the Texas Tribune. The Homeland Security Department's top lawyer, James Percival, posted "We just won 8-1," NBC reported. Fox News and CBS gave no count.
How the Big Bend fight reached the Court
The fight began with three waivers. Then-Homeland Security Secretary Kristi Noem issued one in February, and her successor, Markwayne Mullin, issued two more in May and July. Together they let the government skip laws such as the Endangered Species Act and the National Environmental Policy Act.
In April, three challengers sued: the Center for Biological Diversity, a group restoring a historic church in Ruidosa, and a local river guide. Theirs is one of six suits against the project. Then, in August, bulldozers in the national park set off a backlash, and the border agency paused work inside the park through September, CBS News reported.
On Oct. 2, U.S. District Judge Kathleen Cardone in El Paso blocked the waivers and halted the work. She found the waivers likely broke the major-questions rule, in a region with the border's lowest rate of migrant apprehensions.
Because the 1996 law skips the federal appeals courts, the government went straight to the justices. Its Oct. 21 request asked them to lift the order, and the challengers answered on Oct. 29.
What we don't know yet
We don't know how long the pause will last. Under the order, it holds until the government asks the Court to take the case and the Court decides. If the Court says no, the pause ends on its own; if it says yes, the pause lasts until the case is decided. Meanwhile, the case goes on in El Paso, though the Court said the government is very likely to win its argument that the judge could not hear this claim at all.
We also don't know exactly what will be built in the park. The border agency has promised new plans but has not given a date. And we don't know what the new Democratic majority in Congress will try to do once it is seated in January. The incoming member for the district that includes Big Bend has vowed to fight the wall.
The case each side makes
The administration
The government argues that Congress settled this decades ago. Its filing calls the waiver power a clear grant from Congress that the secretary has used again and again for decades to speed wall building.
It says Big Bend is no low-risk gap. Officials point to more than 89,000 apprehensions in the sector from 2021 through 2025, plus drug seizures and cartels just across the river. Leaving it open, Solicitor General D. John Sauer wrote, would create "a massive vulnerability in border protection." Border agency head Rodney Scott says the agency is "moving forward with critical border security construction."
The challengers and Texas critics
The challengers argue that the region's cliffs and desert already guard the border. They say Big Bend sees only about 0.3% to 2.2% of border apprehensions, the lowest of any southern sector. Their filing warned of "the permanent alteration of an irreplaceable landscape."
Critics include Republicans. Texas Land Commissioner Dawn Buckingham said "Texas can secure our border and protect Big Bend." Terrell County's Republican sheriff called the mountains "big natural barriers." Laiken Jordahl of the Center for Biological Diversity said the administration is "hellbent on destroying" one of America's greatest national parks.
Sources
Left
- NBC News: Supreme Court paves way for Trump to build a section of his border wall in the Big Bend area of Texas, Nov. 9
- Associated Press via NBC 5 Dallas-Fort Worth: Supreme Court clears the way for border wall construction in Texas's Big Bend to resume, Nov. 9
- ABC News: Supreme Court lifts pause on border construction in Big Bend, Texas, Nov. 9
- CBS News: Supreme Court allows Trump administration to resume border wall construction in Big Bend region, Nov. 9 (not on our panel or Secondary list; cited for facts, counts toward no group)
- CNN: Supreme Court allows Trump to continue border wall construction in Big Bend region of Texas, Nov. 9 (headline only; page blocked)
Center
- Reuters: Supreme Court allows Trump border wall at Big Bend National Park in Texas, Nov. 9 (headline only; page blocked)
- The Hill: Supreme Court allows Big Bend border construction to continue in Texas, siding with Trump, Nov. 9 (headline only; page blocked)
- The Wall Street Journal: Supreme Court Lets Trump Administration Build Border Wall in Big Bend, Nov. 9 (headline only; paywalled)
- The Texas Tribune: Trump's Big Bend border wall construction can resume after U.S. Supreme Court ruling, Nov. 9 (nonprofit Texas newsroom; not on our panel or Secondary list; cited for facts, counts toward no group)
- Marfa Public Radio via Texas Public Radio: Plaintiffs in legal fight over the Big Bend border wall react to Supreme Court ruling, Nov. 10 (public radio; not on our panel or Secondary list; cited for facts, counts toward no group)
Right
- Fox News: SCOTUS allows Trump admin to temporarily resume border construction in Texas' Big Bend, Nov. 9
- The Daily Wire: SCOTUS Opens The Door For Trump To Expand Border Wall, Nov. 10
- Washington Examiner: Supreme Court lifts block on Big Bend border wall construction lawsuit, Nov. 9 (opening read; rest behind paywall)
- The Washington Times: Supreme Court allows Trump to build border wall in Texas' Big Bend, Nov. 9 (headline only; page blocked)
Primary
- Supreme Court of the United States: Mullin v. Friends of the Ruidosa Church, No. 26A560, order granting stay, Nov. 9 · Archived copy
- Solicitor General: Application for a stay, No. 26A560, Oct. 21 · Archived copy
- Friends of the Ruidosa Church et al.: Opposition to the application, No. 26A560, Oct. 29 · Archived copy
This article was produced by AI under our Editorial Standards. Corrections are reviewed before they go live.
How coverage differs
Free with a Fair Witness account
See how left, center and right covered this story
A free account shows where the coverage agrees and where it splits, what each side played up and played down, and, when one side's outlets missed a story, who missed it.
Keep reading
The newest stories in U.S., then the rest of the site.
Newest · U.S.
House Democrats seek Cantor Fitzgerald's Nvidia records in Lutnick probe
The letter shows how the House's incoming Democratic chairs plan to test whether Lutnick's handling of Megaspeed was shaped by his family firm's Nvidia stake.
Latest
New stories and updates, newest first. Times are Eastern.
-
Nov 18
3:08 PMTop story U.S.
House Democrats seek Cantor Fitzgerald's Nvidia records in Lutnick probe
The letter shows how the House's incoming Democratic chairs plan to test whether Lutnick's handling of Megaspeed was shaped by his family firm's Nvidia stake.
-
Nov 18
11:40 AMUpdated World
U.S. strikes Iran's Qeshm Island after third Iranian attack on Bahrain, officials say
It is the U.S. reply to Iranian attacks that ended a two-month lull, and Iran's next move will show whether the exchange keeps going.
-
Nov 18
11:39 AMUpdated U.S.
White House counsel warns Oversight Democrats their probes could be criminal
The letter escalates a fight over how far Congress can dig into the Trump administration once Democrats take over in January.
-
Nov 18
11:14 AMUpdated World
Trump will meet Xi and Putin together Thursday to discuss nuclear arms, White House says
No treaty has capped the world's two largest nuclear arsenals since February, and Trump wants China in whatever replaces it.
-
Nov 18
11:14 AMUpdated U.S.
NSA's classified network goes down; White House says no sign of a cyberattack
The intelligence agency's internal system for sharing secrets failed in a week of U.S. tech outages, and Democrats want a briefing.
-
Nov 18
2:55 PMUpdated World
Part of Crimean Bridge collapses after Ukrainian strike as Russia hits Kyiv's bridges
Each side hit bridges it calls military routes, two days before Trump meets Putin and Xi in China.
-
Nov 18
2:37 PMUpdated U.S.
Bessent blames Lutnick's Commerce Department for not blacklisting Megaspeed
The Cabinet split over a chip buyer tied to the Nvidia scandal is a fight over how well the U.S. keeps advanced chips from China.
-
Nov 18
2:16 PMUpdated U.S.
Mullin defends flying government plane to LSU-Texas game a day after FAA ground stop
His department says he paid his way, but federal rules can set that at a coach fare, and no one has said what he paid.
-
Nov 18
2:15 PMUpdated World
Iran fires on U.S. air base in Kuwait and at Bahrain after U.S. strike on Qeshm
Iran's first attack on Kuwait in two months widens a weeklong exchange of fire, and Washington has not said how it will answer.
-
Nov 18
12:41 PMNew World
Britain hands Army officer accused of spying for Russia to U.S. military
The handover moves any prosecution to the United States, where officials have not said whether a military or civilian court would hear it.
Edge of Frame · Right
-
Nov 18
12:30 PMTop story U.S.
Garcia tells Vance, Trump's sons and others to preserve records for House probes
The letters map what Democrats plan to investigate once they take the House in January and gain the power to subpoena.
-
Nov 18
12:25 PMTop story U.S.
House Democrats nominate Hakeem Jeffries for speaker, 251-11, ahead of Jan. 3 vote
Eleven Democrats voted no in a count he asked for. His party's projected majority lets him lose almost 40 votes and still reach 218.
-
Nov 18
11:53 AMUpdated World
US Army soldier arrested in UK on suspicion of spying for Russia
The soldier, who has not been named or charged, was assigned to a NATO headquarters built to respond quickly to crises.
The Fair Witness Daily
Get each morning's Spin Meter in your inbox
The Daily leads with the Spin Meter, then the day's explainers. A free account also unlocks every Spin Meter on the site.
Free. Unsubscribe anytime. Already a member? Sign in