Skip to content
The brick and glass Plymouth Trial Court building in Plymouth, Massachusetts, seen across a wide lawn

U.S.

Judge sets March 29 retrial for Lindsay Clancy in deaths of her three children

A new jury will weigh whether mental illness left her not criminally responsible, after one juror blocked a verdict in September.

Published 7 min read

The Plymouth Trial Court in Plymouth, Massachusetts, home of the Plymouth Superior Court, where Clancy's first trial was held. Photo, July 2013: Kevin Rutherford (Ktr101) / Wikimedia Commons / CC BY-SA 4.0

Who covered this

What these mean

The short version

  • A Massachusetts judge on Monday set March 29, 2027, for Lindsay Clancy's second murder trial in the 2023 deaths of her three children.
  • Her first jury deadlocked in September, so a new jury will weigh whether mental illness left her not criminally responsible.
  • A status hearing is set for Dec. 30, and her lawyers plan to appeal the judge's double jeopardy ruling without delaying the trial.
Documents in this story · 2
  • RulingCommonwealth v. Lindsay Clancy closing arguments (Rev)Transcript · Web pageOpen Archived
  • RulingRichardson v. United States, 468 U.S. 317 (1984)U.S. Supreme Court · Web pageOpen Archived

Lindsay Clancy's murder retrial in the 2023 deaths of her three young children will begin March 29, 2027, a Massachusetts judge ruled Monday.

The date ends two months of doubt about whether there would be a retrial at all. Clancy's first trial ended in September with a jury that could not agree, and her lawyers argued that trying her again would put her in double jeopardy. Judge William Sullivan rejected that argument last week, and on Monday prosecutors told the court they want another jury trial.

Why it matters

The case has drawn national attention to mental illness after childbirth. The retrial will put the same hard question to a new jury: when does an illness mean a person is not to blame under the law? The two answers lead to very different places. A first-degree murder conviction means life in prison without parole. A finding that she was not criminally responsible would send her to a state psychiatric hospital instead.

What the judge decided about the Lindsay Clancy retrial

Clancy, a 36-year-old former nurse, is charged with three counts of first-degree murder. Prosecutors say she strangled her children with exercise bands at the family's Duxbury home on Jan. 24, 2023, according to Reuters and NBC News. She then jumped from a window, and the fall left her paralyzed. Her lawyers did not dispute at trial that she killed the children. They argued she was in the grip of postpartum psychosis.

Monday's hearing in Plymouth was about the calendar, and Sullivan pushed for speed. He told both sides to pick a date in March or April, while prosecutors first sought May and then late April, Fox News reported. Assistant District Attorney Jennifer Sprague pointed to other murder trials already on the court's schedule. Sullivan chose March anyway, telling the lawyers that the sooner a case is retried, "the better it is for all parties."

The judge also has a deadline of his own. He faces mandatory retirement in June 2027, when he turns 70, and the defense had pushed for an early date for that reason, according to USA Today. A status hearing is set for Dec. 30. The outlets differ on one date: USA Today, Fox News and The Daily Wire put the final pretrial conference on Feb. 18, while NBC News reported March 18.

Prosecutors did not say outright which charges they will bring, USA Today reported. Defense lawyer Kevin Reddington said their request for a jury was "an indirect comment from the DA" that they would seek first-degree murder again. CNN reported that prosecutors indicated in court they would retry her on the same first-degree charges. A lesser charge such as second-degree murder would have let Clancy waive a jury and have a judge decide the case, Reuters explained.

How one juror stopped the first trial

The first trial lasted weeks over the summer. Jurors deliberated for seven days before Sullivan declared a mistrial on Sept. 4, Boston.com reported. The foreperson's notes told the judge that one juror would not apply the reasonable doubt standard. Sullivan refused the defense's request to dismiss the holdout. Instead he asked each juror whether they could follow the law and repeated his instructions.

Afterward, some jurors said in televised interviews that they had been ready to find Clancy not criminally responsible. The jury split 11 to 1, with the holdout voting for a murder conviction, according to Fox News and Newsweek. The holdout has publicly disputed his fellow jurors' account of the deliberations, USA Today reported. In closing arguments, the prosecutor framed the question Massachusetts law put to the jury: whether Clancy knew right from wrong and could control her conduct when she killed the children.

Why a retrial isn't double jeopardy

The Constitution's Fifth Amendment bars the government from trying a person twice for the same crime. But a hung jury has long been an exception. In 1824, in a case called United States v. Perez, the Supreme Court said a judge may discharge a jury that cannot agree when there is a manifest necessity, a real need, and the case can be tried again. The Court made the rule plain in Richardson v. United States in 1984: a jury's failure to reach a verdict is not an event that ends a defendant's jeopardy, so a second trial is allowed.

That left Clancy's lawyers a narrower path. Martin Weinberg, one of her attorneys, argued on Nov. 2 that the mistrial wasn't truly necessary, NBC News reported. The judge, he said, should have questioned the holdout and could have replaced him with an alternate, letting deliberations go on.

Sullivan disagreed in a 17-page ruling. He found "there was a manifest necessity for a mistrial based on the jury's deadlock," Fox News reported. The foreperson's notes pointed to a disagreement among jurors, not a refusal to deliberate. And what came out about the juror after the trial can't undo a decision based on what the court knew then, he wrote, as Boston.com summarized it.

The same day, he denied the defense's request for the holdout's records and turned down a prosecution request to limit what the lawyers could say to reporters, according to NBC News.

Sullivan's reasoning matters for the appeal Clancy's lawyers have promised. It puts the focus on whether the mistrial itself was truly necessary, the question Weinberg raised.

there was a manifest necessity for a mistrial based on the jury's deadlock

Judge William Sullivan, in his ruling denying the motion to dismiss, Nov. 9 (Fox News)

What we don't know yet

Prosecutors have not formally said whether they will retry Clancy on first-degree murder or a lesser charge. Plymouth County District Attorney Timothy Cruz had said his office would decide by Monday's hearing, Newsweek reported. As of 11:45 a.m. ET Monday, we found no public statement from his office on the charges.

Neither side has said whether it will make the same arguments a second time. Her lawyers intend to appeal Sullivan's double jeopardy ruling but don't want the appeal to delay the trial, Newsweek reported. Any slip in the schedule could also leave the case to a new judge after Sullivan retires, Fox News reported.

The case each side makes

The prosecution

Prosecutors in Cruz's office argued at trial that Clancy planned the killings and was not in psychosis, NBC News reported. In her closing, Sprague told jurors the question was whether Clancy "knew the difference between right and wrong" at the time, the transcript shows. Mental illness, she argued, did not stop Clancy from knowing the killings were wrong or from controlling what she did, Newsweek reported.

On the retrial, prosecutors told the judge that a mistrial must be judged on what the court knew when it declared one, not on what jurors or the media said later. Sullivan agreed.

The defense

Reddington told jurors that Clancy was a mother in a mental health crisis who did not get the care she needed. "She was reaching out for help and she was not getting it," he said in his closing, Newsweek reported. Her lawyers argued that postpartum psychosis left her unaware of her actions, NBC News reported.

On the retrial, the defense argued the judge ended the first trial too soon by not questioning the holdout, and that a second trial violates her constitutional rights. Weinberg said an appeal to the state's highest court is coming, Boston.com reported.

Sources

This article was produced by AI under our Editorial Standards. Corrections are reviewed before they go live.

Challenge this article

How coverage differs

Free with a Fair Witness account

See how left, center and right covered this story

A free account shows where the coverage agrees and where it splits, what each side played up and played down, and, when one side's outlets missed a story, who missed it.

Share this story

Challenge this article

Found a factual error? Send us published evidence. We review every submission and correct errors in public.

Keep reading

The newest stories in U.S., then the rest of the site.

Newest · U.S.

House Democrats seek Cantor Fitzgerald's Nvidia records in Lutnick probe

The letter shows how the House's incoming Democratic chairs plan to test whether Lutnick's handling of Megaspeed was shaped by his family firm's Nvidia stake.

· 6 min read

The Democrats' Nov. 17 letter asks whether Lutnick's export decisions were shaped by his family firm's holdings. Document: House Judiciary Committee Democrats; graphic: Fair Witness

Latest

New stories and updates, newest first. Times are Eastern.

All updates
  1. Nov 18

    2:55 PMUpdated World

    Part of Crimean Bridge collapses after Ukrainian strike as Russia hits Kyiv's bridges

    Each side hit bridges it calls military routes, two days before Trump meets Putin and Xi in China.

  2. Nov 18

    11:14 AMUpdated World

    Trump will meet Xi and Putin together Thursday to discuss nuclear arms, White House says

    No treaty has capped the world's two largest nuclear arsenals since February, and Trump wants China in whatever replaces it.

  3. Nov 18

    11:14 AMUpdated U.S.

    NSA's classified network goes down; White House says no sign of a cyberattack

    The intelligence agency's internal system for sharing secrets failed in a week of U.S. tech outages, and Democrats want a briefing.

  4. Nov 18

    11:14 AMUpdated Technology

    Apple outage: company says an internal update hit iCloud, Apple Pay and App Store

    Many services were back by afternoon, but Apple's status page for app makers still listed key tools as down Tuesday evening.

  5. Nov 18

    9:15 AMNew Culture

    Pope Leo says no to married priests for now, details his lung cancer surgery

    His answer keeps on hold a 2019 proposal from Amazon bishops to make married deacons priests where communities wait years for one.

  6. Nov 18

    2:16 PMUpdated U.S.

    Mullin defends flying government plane to LSU-Texas game a day after FAA ground stop

    His department says he paid his way, but federal rules can set that at a coach fare, and no one has said what he paid.

  7. Nov 18

    2:15 PMUpdated World

    Iran fires on U.S. air base in Kuwait and at Bahrain after U.S. strike on Qeshm

    Iran's first attack on Kuwait in two months widens a weeklong exchange of fire, and Washington has not said how it will answer.

  8. Nov 18

    12:41 PMNew World

    Britain hands Army officer accused of spying for Russia to U.S. military

    The handover moves any prosecution to the United States, where officials have not said whether a military or civilian court would hear it.

    Edge of Frame · Right

  9. Nov 18

    12:30 PMTop story U.S.

    Garcia tells Vance, Trump's sons and others to preserve records for House probes

    The letters map what Democrats plan to investigate once they take the House in January and gain the power to subpoena.

  10. Nov 18

    12:25 PMTop story U.S.

    House Democrats nominate Hakeem Jeffries for speaker, 251-11, ahead of Jan. 3 vote

    Eleven Democrats voted no in a count he asked for. His party's projected majority lets him lose almost 40 votes and still reach 218.

  11. Nov 18

    11:53 AMUpdated World

    US Army soldier arrested in UK on suspicion of spying for Russia

    The soldier, who has not been named or charged, was assigned to a NATO headquarters built to respond quickly to crises.

  12. Nov 18

    11:40 AMUpdated World

    U.S. strikes Iran's Qeshm Island after third Iranian attack on Bahrain, officials say

    It is the U.S. reply to Iranian attacks that ended a two-month lull, and Iran's next move will show whether the exchange keeps going.

  13. Nov 18

    11:39 AMUpdated U.S.

    White House counsel warns Oversight Democrats their probes could be criminal

    The letter escalates a fight over how far Congress can dig into the Trump administration once Democrats take over in January.

The Fair Witness Daily

Get each morning's Spin Meter in your inbox

The Daily leads with the Spin Meter, then the day's explainers. A free account also unlocks every Spin Meter on the site.

Check your inbox to confirm your subscription.

Free. Unsubscribe anytime. Already a member? Sign in