Skip to content
Close-up of the Facebook app open on an Android smartphone screen

Technology

Out of Frame · Right

Italy fines Meta €805 million over Facebook's access to Android users' photos

Italy's regulator says one app-wide permission isn't consent for a feature that can read a phone's whole photo library.

Published 7 min read

Italy's fine targets a feature inside this app that suggests posts drawn from the photos and videos in a phone's gallery. Photo, January 2019: Tony Webster / Wikimedia Commons / CC BY 2.0

Who covered this

How we flag these

The short version

  • Italy's privacy regulator fined Meta €805 million, saying Facebook's Android app read users' photo galleries without specific consent.
  • About 20 million Android users in Italy were affected, and the ruling says one app-wide permission doesn't cover every feature.
  • Meta has 60 days to switch the feature off by default and ask separately, and the company says it will appeal.
Documents in this story · 3
  • RecordFacebook: il Garante Privacy sanziona Meta per 805 milioni di euro (Italian and English)Garante per la protezione dei dati personali · Web page · Nov. 14, 2026Open Archived
  • RecordCambridge Analytica: il Garante privacy multa Facebook per 1 milione di euroGarante per la protezione dei dati personali · Web page · June 28, 2019Open Archived
  • ReleaseData Protection Commission announces conclusion of inquiry into Meta IrelandIreland's Data Protection Commission · Press release · May 22, 2023Open Archived

Italy's privacy watchdog fined Meta €805 million, about $887 million, saying Facebook's Android app read photos and videos on people's phones without their specific consent.

The money is only part of the order. The watchdog, known as the Garante, said Saturday that Meta has 60 days to turn the feature off by default, even for people who already said yes. Meta must also ask for consent to this feature separately. The company said it disagrees and will appeal.

Why it matters to you

The case is about one tap most people make without reading. If you give Facebook full access to your photos, the app can read your whole photo library and keep reading it over time. Neither you nor a regulator can check what it uses, the Garante found, in a case that covers about 20 million Android users in Italy.

The ruling holds only in Italy, but you can check the same setting yourself. In the Facebook app, Which?, the British consumer group, says it sits under Settings & Privacy, then Settings, then "Camera roll sharing suggestions." On an Android phone, you can also go to Apps, then Facebook, then Permissions, and limit what the app sees of your photos and videos.

What Italy says Facebook's gallery feature did

The feature shows you photos and videos from your own phone as ideas for posts while you scroll. In English reports it goes by "get suggestions from gallery when browsing," and it has been around since 2023.

The problem, the Garante said, is how Facebook asked. The app asked for gallery access once, through a single permission that covered the whole app and several features with different jobs. Before that, users saw a general notice about turning on other features, which didn't tell them they were also turning on gallery suggestions. And the feature was on by default, the Garante said.

Italy's privacy code puts into law an EU rule on what apps can read on your device. That rule "protects the smartphone as part of a person's private sphere," the Garante wrote. So reading what is stored on a phone needs free and informed consent, even if no data leaves the phone and no one is harmed.

The Garante opened its investigation in July 2025 after a complaint from a consumer group in Bolzano, in northern Italy, and ran its own tests of the app. It did not look at whether Meta used the photos to train AI, which Meta denies. Next, its statement said, it may look at a newer feature, launched this year, that sends gallery content to the cloud.

Why Italy, not Ireland, fined Meta

The fine names Meta Platforms Ireland, the company's EU arm, and Meta argued that Ireland's regulator should have handled the case. That is how a 2023 case went under the GDPR, the EU's main privacy law. Ireland's Data Protection Commission wrote a draft ruling and sent it to the other EU regulators for review, a process that ended in a €1.2 billion fine.

This case ran under a different rule. The EU's ePrivacy rules, which cover what apps can read on your phone, have no one-stop shop that sends a case to one lead country. So the Garante turned down Meta's objection and ruled on its own, its statement said. That is why a regulator in Rome, not Dublin, set the size of the fine.

The Garante also said it weighed a 2019 ruling against the company, without naming it. Its own files show that in June 2019 it fined Facebook €1 million over the Cambridge Analytica case. In that case, an outside app took data on more than 200,000 Italian users who had never downloaded it. Saturday's fine is about 800 times as large.

It is also among the largest fines an Italian authority has given a tech company. Amazon's 2021 fine for breaking competition law was bigger, at more than €1.1 billion, but it was cut to €752 million on appeal. So the figure set Saturday may not be the one Meta pays in the end.

What we don't know yet

The timing of Meta's appeal is still unknown, and so is whether a court will pause the 60-day order while it runs. The order itself sets the next deadlines. Meta must tell the Garante within 30 days what steps it has started, and within 90 days what it has done, the statement said. If Meta misses the deadline, the feature can't be turned on for anyone who hasn't given valid consent.

Meta also hasn't said whether it will change the feature for users outside Italy. And the Garante gave no date for its look at the newer cloud feature.

The case each side makes

Italy's privacy watchdog

The Garante's case is that a phone holds a person's private life, so one blanket permission isn't enough. Users couldn't tell from Facebook's notice that saying yes would let the app suggest posts from their gallery. And the feature was on before they chose, it said.

The fine comes to about 0.47% of Meta's global sales. In setting it, the Garante weighed the number of people affected, a breach still going on for users who haven't updated the app, and what it called Meta's limited cooperation. It gave Meta some credit for changes made after the complaint, but called them late and limited to people who update.

protects the smartphone as part of a person's private sphere

Italy's data protection authority, in its Nov. 14 statement (Garante)

Meta

Meta says the Garante got it wrong. A company spokesperson said Meta strongly disagrees with the ruling "and the disproportionate level of the fine," The Guardian reported, citing the French news agency AFP. The spokesperson said Meta would appeal.

In a statement to the BBC, Meta called gallery suggestions "a straightforward feature which helps people post photos and videos to Facebook." It said people must give permission on their phones before the feature works, and can change that permission in their settings at any time.

The company also argued that Italy had no power to decide the case, and that it belonged in Ireland, the Garante's statement said. Meta denies using gallery photos to train AI, and it changed the feature after the complaint.

Sources

Right

None of the 12 right-leaning outlets we track reported this

Checked, no report found as of 11:35 a.m. ET Nov. 15: Fox News, New York Post, The Daily Wire, The Washington Times, The Daily Caller, Just The News, +6.

This article was produced by AI under our Editorial Standards. Corrections are reviewed before they go live.

Challenge this article

How coverage differs

Free with a Fair Witness account

See how left, center and right covered this story

A free account shows where the coverage agrees and where it splits, what each side played up and played down, and, when one side's outlets missed a story, who missed it.

Share this story

Challenge this article

Found a factual error? Send us published evidence. We review every submission and correct errors in public.

Keep reading

The newest stories in Technology, then the rest of the site.

Newest · Technology

Officials see no sign of cyberattack behind week of tech outages; lawmakers want answers

The intelligence chief blames a rush of security upgrades, but lawmakers in both parties want a fuller account of why so much failed at once.

· 7 min read

Composite of official portraits: Jay Clayton (left), director of national intelligence, and Josh Hawley (right), now a Missouri senator, as state attorney general, 2017–19. Photos: Office of the Director of National Intelligence / Wikimedia Commons / Public domain (left); Missouri State Archives / Wikimedia Commons / Public domain (right)

Latest

New stories and updates, newest first. Times are Eastern.

All updates
  1. Nov 18

    2:55 PMUpdated World

    Part of Crimean Bridge collapses after Ukrainian strike as Russia hits Kyiv's bridges

    Each side hit bridges it calls military routes, two days before Trump meets Putin and Xi in China.

  2. Nov 18

    11:14 AMUpdated World

    Trump will meet Xi and Putin together Thursday to discuss nuclear arms, White House says

    No treaty has capped the world's two largest nuclear arsenals since February, and Trump wants China in whatever replaces it.

  3. Nov 18

    11:14 AMUpdated U.S.

    NSA's classified network goes down; White House says no sign of a cyberattack

    The intelligence agency's internal system for sharing secrets failed in a week of U.S. tech outages, and Democrats want a briefing.

  4. Nov 18

    11:14 AMUpdated Technology

    Apple outage: company says an internal update hit iCloud, Apple Pay and App Store

    Many services were back by afternoon, but Apple's status page for app makers still listed key tools as down Tuesday evening.

  5. Nov 18

    9:15 AMNew Culture

    Pope Leo says no to married priests for now, details his lung cancer surgery

    His answer keeps on hold a 2019 proposal from Amazon bishops to make married deacons priests where communities wait years for one.

  6. Nov 18

    2:16 PMUpdated U.S.

    Mullin defends flying government plane to LSU-Texas game a day after FAA ground stop

    His department says he paid his way, but federal rules can set that at a coach fare, and no one has said what he paid.

  7. Nov 18

    2:15 PMUpdated World

    Iran fires on U.S. air base in Kuwait and at Bahrain after U.S. strike on Qeshm

    Iran's first attack on Kuwait in two months widens a weeklong exchange of fire, and Washington has not said how it will answer.

  8. Nov 18

    12:41 PMNew World

    Britain hands Army officer accused of spying for Russia to U.S. military

    The handover moves any prosecution to the United States, where officials have not said whether a military or civilian court would hear it.

    Edge of Frame · Right

  9. Nov 18

    12:30 PMTop story U.S.

    Garcia tells Vance, Trump's sons and others to preserve records for House probes

    The letters map what Democrats plan to investigate once they take the House in January and gain the power to subpoena.

  10. Nov 18

    12:25 PMTop story U.S.

    House Democrats nominate Hakeem Jeffries for speaker, 251-11, ahead of Jan. 3 vote

    Eleven Democrats voted no in a count he asked for. His party's projected majority lets him lose almost 40 votes and still reach 218.

  11. Nov 18

    11:53 AMUpdated World

    US Army soldier arrested in UK on suspicion of spying for Russia

    The soldier, who has not been named or charged, was assigned to a NATO headquarters built to respond quickly to crises.

  12. Nov 18

    11:40 AMUpdated World

    U.S. strikes Iran's Qeshm Island after third Iranian attack on Bahrain, officials say

    It is the U.S. reply to Iranian attacks that ended a two-month lull, and Iran's next move will show whether the exchange keeps going.

  13. Nov 18

    11:39 AMUpdated U.S.

    White House counsel warns Oversight Democrats their probes could be criminal

    The letter escalates a fight over how far Congress can dig into the Trump administration once Democrats take over in January.

The Fair Witness Daily

Get each morning's Spin Meter in your inbox

The Daily leads with the Spin Meter, then the day's explainers. A free account also unlocks every Spin Meter on the site.

Check your inbox to confirm your subscription.

Free. Unsubscribe anytime. Already a member? Sign in